Where Was Jesus Born In A Stable

Jesus was not born in a stable, says theologian

Christmas nativity scenes across the world depict the birth of Christ, which may be the most famous Bible tale of all: Jesus was born in a stable because there were no rooms available at the inn when his parents went to give birth to him. Christian scholar Rev Ian Paul, on the other hand, has suggested that the entire tale of Jesus’ birth may be based on a misunderstanding of the New Testament, resurrecting an old belief that Jesus was not, in fact, born in a stable. “I apologize for interfering with your Christmas preparations before the Christmas lights have even been turned on,” writes Rev Paul, a theologian and former Dean of Studies at St John’s Theological College in Nottingham, on his personal blog.

For a “Inn” or any other establishment where visitors are welcomed, a completely separate term, pandocheion, is used.

His family was in Bethlehem, and if he did have family there, the norms of first-century Palestine compelled him to remain with them rather than with strangers, which was the sole reason they traveled there for the census.

It’s possible that the place was already crammed with other relatives who had come before them.

  1. There would typically be hollows in the ground filled with straw in the family living space where the animals would feed,” says the author.
  2. This is hardly a novel way of looking at things.
  3. Because of his suffering, he was denounced to the inquisition and admonished by them, albeit he was not really burnt, tortured, or imprisoned as would have happened to other heretics.
  4. “In the Christmas tale, Jesus is not depressed and lonely, lying in a manger far away from us and requiring our sympathy.

If this occurred in a busy family house, the message is still intact. In his opinion, the fact that it took place in an isolated stable “only serves to demonstrate that the decline was from a respected human to a despised human.”

Was Jesus born in a stable?

There’s no room at the inn. She wrapped Him in a blanket and placed Him in a manger. Is it possible to be in a manger but not in a stable? We are well familiar with the Christmas narrative. As Mary and Joseph made their journey from Nazareth to Bethlehem, they were turned away by the innkeeper from staying at the local inn. After fleeing to a barn, where baby Jesus was born and languished in agony, they were saved. According to a very old church belief, the place of the Nativity was a cave near Bethlehem.

  1. Dr.
  2. Our hypothesis is that the narrative does not allude to aninn, acave, or even abarn, but rather to ahouse!
  3. Unfortunately, the Greek name for inn (kataluma) had numerous connotations, including inn and caravansary, which made it difficult to interpret.
  4. Dr.
  5. A furnished huge upper storey apartment in a privateJerusalemhouse, according to him, was what it was.
  6. We propose that thekatalumaof Jesus’ first night in Bethlehem was a chamber identical to this one.
  7. When they got at Joseph’s ancestral house, they saw that it was already crowded with other family members who had arrived earlier in the day.

It appears that this is the time when Mary and Joseph went to the barn.

Since the manger is not mentioned in the Biblical story, it is thought that the barn and cave were not present.

Manners may be found within the walls of homes throughout history, including those of the ancient world and early modern nations.

A limited number of flock animals were kept in one of the home’s ground-floor rooms, rather than in the sheds that were linked to the house on the outside.

Food was made and perhaps consumed in this location as well.

The animals were safe from the elements and theft since they were kept indoors.

Numerous installations within household structures in Israel have been discovered during excavations, which are thought to represent ancient mangers.

Wooden mangers, on the other hand, have not survived to the present day in the archaeological record.

Instead, they stayed downstairs in the household stable, which was still part of the ancient residence and included a couple of mangers for the animals.

Because God so loved the world that He gave His only born Son, that whomever believes in Him should not perish, but have eternal life, we may say that God has saved the world.

Answers for doubters.

Provided by the Association for Biblical Research, Faith Builder Card2, which is available through the organization.

Copyright 1995, Associates for Biblical Research, All Rights Reserved—except as noted on the attached”Usage and Copyright”page, which grants ChristianAnswers.Net users generous rights for putting

this page to work in their homes, personal witnessing, churches, and schools. Copyright 1995, Associates for Biblical Research, All Rights Reserved—except as noted on the attached”Usage and Copyright”page, which grants ChristianAnswers.Net users generous rights for putting

Was Jesus Born in a Stable, a Cave or a House?

Is it possible that Jesus was born in a stable? Is it possible that it was a cave? Alternatively, how about a house? The simple answer to this question is that we do not know. Unfortunately, we can’t be positive because the Bible does not expressly address this issue. We can, however, reason our way through this using the Bible, and we may speculate on where Jesus might have been born as well. A stable is where it is said that Jesus was born, according to tradition. That assertion is founded on the fact that Jesus was laid in a manger at the time of His birth.

Also, the following will serve as a sign unto you: you will discover the child lying in a manger clothed in swaddling cloths.

A Stable or a Cave?

A manger (also known as a phatne) was a sort of animal feed trough. As a result, nativity representations that portray a baby in a straw-filled feeding trough are largely realistic in terms of biblical interpretation (during that time feed troughs were made of stone, not wood). Due to the fact that Jesus was “laid in a manger” (Luke 2:7), it is likely that there were animals around, as depicted in traditional nativity scenes. The Bible, on the other hand, does not inform us that there were any animals there or that His birth took place in a barn.

Historical documents reveal that animals were also maintained in caves around the first century AD, according to historical archives.

A manger, a phatne, a fodder crib, or a cattle stall are the only things that are mentioned.

A House?

Other theories about Jesus’ birth include that he was born in the basement of a house, which is highly plausible and perceptive, although it is not frequently accepted. According to the Bible, Joseph journeyed to Bethlehem, the city of their forefather David, with his betrothed bride Mary in order to comply with the census mandated by Caesar Augustus, who was then in power (Luke 2:1). This would have been a significant difficulty for Mary and Joseph – physically for Mary because of her pregnancy, and financially for Joseph because they had few financial resources at the time.

As a result of this reasoning, it is possible that Joseph and Mary sought accommodation with a relative in Bethlehem.

We should also examine the fact that their journey to Bethlehem was likely to have been extremely delayed due to Mary’s condition, which was that she was almost full term pregnant.

Consequently, if they traveled to the home of a cousin, it is possible that the house had already been occupied by other relatives who had also come to comply with the census.

The Inn?

What about Luke 2:7, on the other hand? It is stated in the verse above that they went to an inn rather than a relative’s house. Luke 2:7And she gave birth to her firstborn son, wrapped him in swaddling cloths, and placed him in a manger, because there was no space for them at the inn where they were staying. The English term “inn,” which appears in Luke 2:7, is often taken as meaning paid accommodation; nevertheless, it might be referring to something different. Do you think it’s the residence of a relative?

  1. Strong’s Dictionary defines Kataluma as follows: from G2647; prop.
  2. (by implication) a lodging-place: –guestchamber at a hotel.
  3. In Greek, kataluo means to loosen up (disintegrate), which means to demolish (literally or figuratively) anything; specifically, to halt for the night:–destroy, dissolve; be guest; lodge; come to naught; overturn; hurl down; to loosen up (disintegrate); to loosen up (disintegrate).
  4. As a place of rest, accommodation, or guest quarters it is defined as follows: Neither public lodgings nor paid accommodations are mentioned in this section.
  5. The innkeeper is an addition to the story, and he is frequently shown in nativity plays.
  6. The suggestion of an innkeeper really adds to what is already stated in the biblical text.

The Guest Chamber?

The upper room serves as a guest chamber, while the lower level serves as a shelter for animals from the first century. The term kataluma is also used in the book of Luke. In this passage, a different word is used to translate the same phrase: 22:11 (Luke 22:11) In such case, you will inform the housekeeper that “the Master has asked thee, Where is the guestchamber, where I shall eat the Passover with my disciples?” will be spoken to him. The word “kataluma” is translated as “guest room” in this context.

This is a reference to a room on the second floor of a home.

An allusion to a guest chamber may also be found in the Gospel of Mark: 14:14 (Mark 14:14) Then, whenever he enters a home, tell the goodman of the house: “The Master asks, “Where is the guestchamber, where I shall enjoy the Passover with my disciples?” It is in the upper room, as described in these passages from Luke 22 and Mark 14, that Jesus shared His final supper with His disciples on the night before He was betrayed.

No, this was not an apartment; it was an upstairs room, a guest chamber (katalu), located in the home of an acquaintance. It was not a “inn” in the traditional sense of a place where people paid to stay or be accommodated.

When an Inn is Really an Inn

The term “inn” is also used in the parable of the Good Samaritan, which is an English word. As implied by the paragraph, this certainly denotes paid lodgings. Although it is a translation from a Greek term with an entirely different meaning, 10:34 (Luke 10:34) And went to him, bandaged up his wounds with oil and wine, and placed him on his own beast, escorting him to aninn, where he was cared for by the villagers. 10:35 (Luke 10:35) And the next morning, before he left, he took out two pennies from his pocket and gave them to the host, telling him to take care of him and that anything he spent in excess of that would be reimbursed to him when he returned.

See also:  Why Was Jesus Sent By God

The Greek word for “host” in verse 35, according to Strong’s Concordance, is described as “an innkeeper (warden of a caravanserai)–host.” There is clear doubt that the inn where the Good Samaritan slept in Luke 10 was a paying establishment, and the host was an innkeeper who was compensated for his services by the Good Samaritan.

  • If it had been a paid accommodation, why wouldn’t Luke have used the right phrase to express that it was a paid accommodation?
  • His works are meticulous and exacting in both concept and word choice.
  • Most scholars believe the Greek word “kataluma” in Luke 2:7 was intended to refer to a “guest chamber” in a residence.
  • Even after taking into consideration the fact that Mary and Joseph were most likely turned away from a relative’s house, the question of where they found shelter remains unanswered.

Upper Room vs Lower Level

During biblical times, the upper level of a two-story house would have served as the dining and sleeping facilities for the family. During severe weather, the bottom floor was frequently utilized as a shelter for the cattle on the property. Our knowledge of the situation is that Mary and Joseph were turned away because there was no room in the guest chamber (the top room, known in Greek as the kataluma), although it is possible that they were provided sanctuary at the lower level among the animals.

  1. This does raise the question of why a relative would refuse to let a pregnant lady into their home.
  2. Before she married Joseph, Mary had discovered that she was pregnant.
  3. Because betrothal was legally binding, much like marriage, Joseph even had the authority to put Mary to death (Matthew 1:18-19) for having committed adultery, despite the fact that the relationship was not legally binding.
  4. It was only after he made the choice to “send her away quietly” (Mat 1:19) that an angel appeared to him and revealed the news of Jesus’ pregnancy.

Because they were unaware of what had been revealed to Mary and Joseph, the family would have assumed Mary was pregnant with Joseph’s illegitimate child, as would have been the case (or another). Nobody knew she was expecting the genuine Son of God since they had no means of knowing.

Rejected by His Own

Possibly, this should be seen as the first instance of Jesus’ rejection by the people. In the same manner that Mary and Jesus were turned away, Jesus himself was turned away. Even before He was born, He was rejected by those closest to Him: ‘He came to his own, and his own did not accept him,’ says John 1:11.

Still Only A Theory

This notion of Jesus being born at a lower level of a house is both plausible and quite likely to be correct. But keep in mind that this is still simply a theory. The Bible merely mentions that they were turned down for a room in a guest chamber and that Jesus was put in a manger after being rejected by them.

40+ Days Later

It has been reported that “after the days of purification according to the law of Moses had been completed, they transported him to Jerusalem, to bring him before the Lord.” (See Luke 2:22.) It had been more than 40 days since the birth of Jesus when this occurred. According to Luke 2:21, Jesus’ circumcision would have taken place eight days after birth, while Mary’s purification would have taken 33 days (Leviticus 12). It was only after these 40+ days that they were able to travel to Jerusalem and visit the Temple.

The landowner (perhaps a relative?) may have felt sympathy for Mary, Joseph, and Jesus following the departure of the upper room occupants and offered them to relocate from the lower to the higher level.

Conclusion

I cannot emphasize enough that this hypothesis is based only on God’s Word and not on any other sources. The Bible doesn’t tell us what sort of shelter Jesus was born in, so we have to guess. The fact that, at the outset of Jesus’ life, He was turned away from an upper room because the people did not know that Mary would give birth to the Messiah is fascinating to contemplate. They had no idea who her kid was, and they were not willing to create place for Him in their lives. Even while still in the womb, Jesus was rejected by His family, and only a handful of loyal witnesses were present to witness the birth of the Christ Child.

During their time in the upper room, they were in close company, and following Judas’ departure, Jesus revealed to the faithful eleven astounding revelations and bestowed several rewards.

This hypothesis of Jesus’ birth at a lower level of a house provides answers to numerous problems while also posing a number of new questions.

God sent His son to earth, to be conceived in the womb of a young woman, to be born in humble circumstances, to live a sinless human life, and then to present Himself to the world as the sinless Lamb of God, thereby completing the work His Father had commissioned Him to do—to atone for the sins of the entire world.

Remember that the sacrifice of the cross began in the cradle, and that we would not have the Calvary Cross if it were not for the Christmas Cradle.

In Isaiah 9:6, the Bible says In fact, God loved the world so much that he gave his only born Son, in order that whomever believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life with him.

Because God did not send his Son into the world in order to condemn the world, but in order that the world could be saved through him. (See also John 3:16-17.) THE REASON FOR THE SEASON IS JESUS CHRIST! *}}}

Born in a Barn (Stable)?

Is it possible that Jesus was born among the animals in the stable because there was no room at the inn for Joseph and Mary? In this article, Tim Chaffey of AiG–US investigates this widely believed idea. Misconception: Jesus was born in a stable among the animals because there was no room at the inn for Joseph and Mary and they had to stay with the animals. Several years ago, I was in attendance at a Christmas performance put on by members of a local congregation. The innkeeper was the major character in the play.

The innkeeper, on the other hand, was able to get them a place to stay at one of the nearby stables.

The following information is recounted in the second chapter of Luke regarding Christ’s birth: The other day, Joseph traveled from Galilee, away from the city of Nazareth, into Judea, to the city of David, which is known as Bethlehem because he was descended from the house and lineage of David, in order to be registered with Mary, his betrothed wife, who was expecting a child with him.

  1. Her firstborn Son was born, and she cradled Him in her arms and put Him in a manger because there was no room for them at the inn where they had been staying.
  2. (Luke 2:4–7) Many people may be surprised to learn that the Bible does not offer us with many additional information concerning the birth of Jesus Christ than what we have already learned.
  3. According to Matthew 1:24–25, Joseph chose Mary as his wife “She was his wife, but he did not know her until after she had given birth to her firstborn Son.
  4. We must consider a few factors when contrasting the modern recounting of the birth of Jesus with the historical accuracy of the Bible.
  5. It is exceedingly improbable that the two would try the grueling 70-mile journey from Nazareth when she is in the latter stages of her pregnancy, as she is in the final stages of her pregnancy.
  6. Second, there is no reference in the Bible of any innkeeper who informed them that the inn was completely booked for the night.
  7. 1 When Jesus spoke of a “guest chamber” inLuke 22:11, he was using the same Greek term.

Most individuals who are familiar with the conventional telling of the Christmas story will find this to be unconvincing at best.

35) to care for the guy.

Why didn’t Luke use the right phrase for an inn in his account of Jesus’ birth, given that he was well-versed in the language of hospitality?

There was no place for them in thekataluma, which would be a better translation of “guest chamber” in the Bible, according to the Bible.

2 Many Jewish families would have needed to come to Bethlehem during this time period, and they would have stayed with relatives who lived in the town because the census had been announced across the Roman Empire.

The result would have been that Joseph and Mary would have been confined to residing on the bottom floor of the house.

Archaeologists have discovered first-century dwellings in the Judean hill area, which they believe to be from the Roman period.

In order to protect the more fragile animals from the cold and theft, it was common practice to bring them in during the night.

The notion of keeping animals in the house is supported by the Scriptures in several ways.

He appeared to be anticipating the arrival of a wild animal outside his home.

As a result, there appears to be biblical precedence for keeping animals in the home.

Mary most likely gave birth to Jesus on the lowest floor of a busy house, where some of the animals had been brought in for the night before she gave birth.

4 Of course, we should never become so preoccupied with the little aspects of this narrative that we lose sight of the main message.

Because of this, the descendants of Adam have a chance to be spared from an eternity of being separated from their Creator.

Because God delivered His Son to our planet in the form of a human being, it is the greatest gift that could ever be offered. Let us rejoice in this fact and spread the word of God’s incredible love across the world.

Jesus wasn’t born in a stable—and that makes all the difference

Putting up Christmas decorations (which I always do far too early), finding a Christmas tree, preparing for carol services, and deciding where to buy your turkey are all part of the annual Christmas routine, which also includes my posting the argument that Jesus did not come into the world in a stable. I intend to continue with this annual ritual since it is, in fact, rather significant in my life. In doing so, it reveals how much we interpret Scripture through the prism of our own preconceptions, culture and traditions, as well as how difficult it may be to read well-known verses carefully and attentively, paying attention to what they truly say.

See also:  Who Played Judas In Jesus Christ Superstar 2018

To put it another way, the belief that Jesus was lonely and dejected at his birth, cast out amongst the animals and sidelined, actually distorts the meaning of the birth narratives, in which (contrary to this tradition) Jesus and his birth are a powerfully disruptive force, bursting into ordinary life and offering the possibility of its transformation.

We find it difficult to maintain our usual routines and customs, especially when we must leave our homes in order to travel to a cold and drafty structure in order to make the once-a-year journey to a site of devotion, as so many people do, as we have done (and mostly do not return in the New Year).

  • So let’s get started.
  • It is important to note that Jesus was not given birth in a stable and that, oddly enough, the New Testament makes no mention of this possibility.
  • There are three factors that I would attribute as the source: conventional elaboration, grammatical and semantic difficulties, and a lack of understanding of first-century Palestinian society.
  • The ox recognizes its master, and the donkey recognizes its owner’s manger, but Israel does not recognize, and my people do not comprehend.
  • After all, isn’t that where animals are kept?
  • This is likely the crux of the problem.
  • (AV).

In addition, the word’s etymology is fairly broad in scope.

However, its application in other contexts has provided some rather conclusive evidence in the other direction.

This appears to be a reception room in a private residence.

The following pair of definitions clearly illustrates the distinction: In Greek, the term kataluma refers to “the spare or upper chamber in a private house or in a community where travelers enjoyed hospitality and for which no money was expected” (ISBE 2004).

The pandokeion consisted of a communal refectory and dormitory, with no private rooms assigned to passengers (Firebaugh 1928).

The fact that Joseph was welcomed by family members upon his return to his ancestral home, even if they were not close relatives, would have been unimaginable in the first instance.

” “Can we be of assistance to you?” Regardless of whether or not Joseph had a member of his extended family living in the hamlet, he felt obligated to seek them out out of respect.

Furthermore, the real architecture of Palestinian homes (which continues to this day) helps to make sense of the entire event.

Hollows in the ground, stocked with hay, would typically be found near the family living space, where the animals would be fed while the family was at home.

In Matthew 5.15, Jesus makes the following observation: “Neither do people light a lamp and place it beneath a bowl.” Instead, they place it on a stand, and it illuminates the entire home, illuminating everyone.

Jesus makes the following observation after curing a lady on the Sabbath (Luke 13.10–17): “Doesn’t everyone of you on the Sabbath take your cow or donkey out of the stable and lead it out to give it water?” Not surprisingly, none of Jesus’ detractors react with the words “No, I don’t handle animals on the Sabbath,” since they would have had to remove their animals from the home if they had.

  • It indicates that a large number of people, including Joseph and Mary, have traveled to Bethlehem, and that the family guest room is already filled, most likely due to the arrival of other relatives who arrived earlier.
  • The hay-filled depressions at the bottom end of the house, where the animals are fed, are the most natural places to put the newborn.
  • In truth, it’s difficult to be alone in such situations in the first place.
  • Every day and night, one cannot be alone since there is no such thing as a private room.
  • In the Christmas story, Jesus is not depressed and lonely, sitting in a stable some distance away and requiring our sympathy.
  • This should have a significant impact on our approach to enacting and preaching on the Christmas story.
  • This view of the tale, which is well-informed and convincing, has been around for a very long time, even in Western academics.

So, why has the incorrect, conventional view endured for such a long period of time?

First and foremost, we find it extremely difficult to understand the narrative in its own cultural context, and we find ourselves continuously imposing our own beliefs about life on the story.

Well, if you live in the Western world, particularly in an urban environment, away from your family, of course!

When I was growing up in Switzerland, I remember noticing the cattle pen underneath the family home.

In his excellent chapter in We Proclaim the Word of Life, Dick France explores this issue, as well as other aspects of preaching on the infancy narratives, in addition to other aspects of preaching.

Initially, when I began advocating Bailey’s interpretation, it was picked up by a Sunday newspaper and then broadcast on various radio programs as a typical example of theological wrecking, on a par with the Bishop of Durham’s then-famous debunking of the reality of the resurrection.

Yes, if you believe that what people need to hear is the actual story of Scripture, rather than the tradition of a children’s play, then yes, it is appropriate.

Even his birth is placed in a unique context, in some ways as removed from everyday life as if he had been born in Caesar’s Palace itself.

He came to be what we are, and it is consistent with that theology that his birth took place in a normal, crowded, warm, and welcoming Palestinian home, just like many other Jewish boys of his time, just like many other Jewish boys of his time.

Even strangers may begin to inquire as to how we read the Bible and comprehend it for ourselves.

This was the subject of a sermon I delivered at a Carol Service, which you can read here.

The paper was originally published in NTS in 2010, but it is now available for free on Carlson’s blog.

He examines the word kataluma in a broad sense, noting in particular that it is used to translate a wide variety of Hebrew terms for ‘places to stay’ in the Septuagint (LXX, the Greek translation of the Old Testament from Hebrew in the second century BC), which was written in the first century BC.

  1. 2.
  2. In his opinion, two factors lead him to believe that Bethlehem was not only Joseph’s ancestral home, but also his actual family home.
  3. Second, he argues that the phrase in Luke 2.39’to a town of their own, Nazareth’ does not imply that they were returning to their home town, but rather that they had moved to this town and made it their permanent residence there.
  4. After Jesus is born, they return together to Mary’s hometown to establish a home near her family.
  5. After reading this, I remembered that I had stayed in exactly such a roof-room in 1981, which had been jerry-built on the roof of a hotel in the Old City of Jerusalem, near the Jaffa Gate, and had been a jerry-built roof-room in 1981.
  6. (You can book a room there as well, by clicking here.) On the site, you can see the view from the roof that we had!) If you found this article useful, please consider sharing it on social media (Facebook or Twitter) using the buttons on the left.
  7. Like my Facebook page if you like it.
  8. If you found this post useful, you can make a one-time or recurring donation through PayPal by clicking on the following link: Policy on comments: Good comments that engage with the content of the post and participate in a respectful debate can add significant value to the conversation.

Make the most charitable interpretation of other people’s points of view and seek to learn from their experiences and perspectives. Don’t think of debate as a battle to be won; instead, focus on the issue at hand rather than the person involved.

Jesus Born in a Stable (Luke 2:1-20)

DO YOU HAVE ANY IDEA WHO THIS LITTLE CHILD IS? It is, in fact, Jesus. He has only recently been born in a barn. A stable is a place where animals are housed. Mary is placing Jesus in the manger, which is the location where donkeys and other farm animals may get their food from to feed themselves. The reason, however, for Mary and Joseph’s presence with the animals is unclear. Is this really the best spot to give birth to a child? No, it is not the case. However, this is the reason they have come: The emperor of Rome, Caesar Augustus, enacted a legislation requiring everyone to return to the city where he was born in order to get his name inscribed in a book, which is still in effect today.

  1. However, when he and Mary arrived, they discovered that there was no place for them anywhere.
  2. And it was on this very day that Mary gave birth to Jesus.
  3. Can you make out the shepherds on their way to visit Jesus?
  4. It turned out to be an angel!
  5. “Don’t be scared,” the angel assured them.’ I have some wonderful news to share with you.
  6. He is going to save the people!
  7. Suddenly, a large number of angels appeared and began worshipping God.

Do you know what it is about Jesus that makes him so special?

As you may recall, the first chapter of this book contained the account of God’s first Son, Jesus.

This, after all, is who Jesus is!

Almost immediately, a baby began to develop within her, just as other infants develop within their mothers.

See also:  What Day Was Jesus Resurrected

Finally, here in Bethlehem, in a stable, was the birth of Jesus.

Was Jesus Born in a Barn, Cave, or House? · Living Theologically

Changes made on December 5th, 2011: This post has been somewhat revised and republished on my new website. You may find it on the Youth Pastor Theologian website. The answer to the question “Where was Jesus born?” is surprisingly difficult to determine. “In Bethlehem,” is a straightforward response. Yes, but where exactly? The traditional nativity scene depicts the holy family in a stable that resembles a barn, which is distinct from the Inn since there was no room in the inn. Is this, however, correct?

  1. What We Already Know Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem, where there was no space “in the inn,” and his being wrapped and put in a manger are all well-documented events in the Bible.
  2. And, while they were there, the time arrived for her to give birth to their child.
  3. Animals were kept in a variety of locations in ancient Bethlehem.
  4. The Most Common Assumption: In a Barn, to be precise.
  5. The explanation for this is understandable and goes as follows: Because Jesus was put in a manger, which was a feeding trough for cattle, it is reasonable to assume that he was born in the stable with the livestock.
  6. This is where farmers currently keep their livestock.
  7. The Traditional Perspective: A Cave The Early Church Fathers described Jesus’ birth as taking place in a cave.

During the reign of Emperor Constantine, the cave that was traditionally believed to be the place of Jesus’ birth was transformed into a holy site, which is today known as the ” Church of the Nativity.” The residents of Bethlehem were rumored to have kept their flocks in an adjacent cave, and there is archaeological evidence of livestock being kept in caverns dating back thousands of years.

  • It is very likely that Origen and Jerome just followed Justin Martyr’s notion and, as a result, they are all incorrect – a position that has gained popularity in recent years.
  • The graphic below is a recreation of what Bethlehem’s dwellings looked like in the past.
  • The top level served as the family’s principal dwelling, and it was always equipped with a “upper room” that could be used as a guest room when guests came to visit.
  • When it reads in Luke 2:7 that “there was no place for them in the inn,” the Greek word for “inn” refers to this particular guest room, not a hotel (there was a word for that, which is used in the Parable of the Good Samaritan).

This viewpoint also reflects the cultural importance placed on hospitality, as well as the high likelihood that Mary’s family would refuse to welcome her and Joseph while she is in her final day(s) of pregnancy, despite the scandal surrounding her being pregnant before their official marriage was finalized.

  1. This point of view is also supported by renowned Bible dictionaries (see their articles for the terms “manger” and “inn” for examples).
  2. This last perspective is something I’ve only lately discovered.
  3. A key point raised by this viewpoint is that Bethlehem’s shepherds had been assigned the particular responsibility of giving birth to and caring for the lambs that would be used for temple sacrifice.
  4. Swaddling cloths were used to protect lambs from damage while they were being put in mangers, exactly as Jesus Christ was wrapped in swaddling clothes and laid in a manger.
  5. You may learn more about ithere by reading about it or watching a video about it.
  6. The million-dollar question is: what should I do?
  7. We’ve figured out all we need to know.
  8. Despite his modest and lowly origins, Jesus was born in Bethlehem.
  9. The information provided above helps to fill in the context in various respects, which may be beneficial while considering the difficulties that Mary and Joseph encountered and when celebrating God’s providence.
  10. Remember, in the middle of the ambiguous facts and whichever hypothesis you think to be the most plausible, to keep your eyes on the wonder: that a plain manger was transformed into God’s throne.

This is the purpose of the tale, and we must not lose sight of it because we are engrossed with the details that God did not consider significant enough to be preserved.

Was Jesus Really Born in a Stable?

If you have already completed your nativity scene, you have most likely placed the figures in a charming, wooden stable shed. They take refuge there under a flimsy roof and rough timbers, with the animals, the shepherds, Mary and Joseph, and the three wise men who came to worship at Bethlehem. But hold on a sec. Was Jesus actually born in a barn because there was no room in the inn where his parents were staying? Understanding the birth of Jesus better comes from a thorough study of the Scriptures, as well as further knowledge of the historical and cultural contexts in which they were written.

When they learned that the infant was born in a stable, they immediately thought of a “humiliating cattle shed,” as well.

Francis was the first to set up a Christmas creche complete with a stable scene.

It was decided to create carols and retell the event, and as the stories grew in popularity, more delightful details were added: the cow and ass knelt down to adore the Lord, and a tiny shepherd lad played his drum for the Christ child.

The Upper Room

Was there “no room at the inn” as the saying goes? The Greek term kataluma, which is rendered as “inn” in the older copies of the English Bible, means “innkeeper.” This is the same word that was used to refer to the “upper room” where the Last Supper took place. It might simply refer to an upstairs room or an additional area that was utilized as a guest room, depending on the context. It’s for this reason that current translations of the Bible will read things like “There was no place for them in the guest room of the home.

It is quite doubtful that there was any form of business inn on the premises.

Instead of being confined to a drafty outbuilding by strangers, Mary and Joseph were treated much like any other large family having overnight family guests and setting up a few extra mattresses in the den or the basement.

The Stable and the Cave

During the time of Justin Martyr, who lived in the vicinity of Judea and wrote just 80 or 90 years after the death and resurrection of Jesus, it was said that Mary gave birth in a cave in Bethlehem, and that the local people in Bethlehem were aware of the location. After Justin Martyr finished writing, the Roman emperor Hadrian constructed an Adonis temple on the site of Christ’s birth in Bethlehem in order to discourage the Christian worship that was already taking place there. This was not long after Justin Martyr finished writing.

Helena, the mother of the emperor Constantine, converted to Christianity some two hundred years after that event had place.

Pilgrims may still visit the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, where they can see the cave where Jesus was born on the church’s lower level, which is still standing today.

What is the significance of the fact that Jesus was born in a cave?

He certainly wasn’t a caveman! It is true that cave dwelling people have been in the Middle East since antiquity, and the Bethlehem region is one of the regions where cave dwellings have been not just the most prevalent, but where some Palestinians continue to live in cave dwellings now.

The Cave Dwellers of Bethlehem

Shepherds’ Caverns Still Dot the Holy Land, a 1987 article, tells us about the people who live in caves near Bethlehem and how they came to be there. These Arabs live solitary, pastoral lifestyles that, with a few exceptions, have changed little since the time of Jesus, says Nissim Krispil, 39, an Israeli expert of Arab folklore, history, and traditions in the West Bank who has written a five-volume encyclopedia on the topic. A seventeen-year-old shepherd from near Bethlehem, Mohammed is interviewed by the author of the article.

  1. The elevated section, known as amastaba, in the cavern where Mohammed and his family dwell has been constructed by humans and serves as a sleeping and dining place.
  2. A weekly application of ammonia to the cave floor helps to disinfect it while also neutralizing the unpleasant stench left by the animals.
  3. The stable is located at a lower elevation.
  4. It was already full with family members when Mary and Joseph arrived at the cave residence, so they were granted space in the bottom room, which was also warm and home to the animals when they arrived.

The Real Details Fit Perfectly With the Gospel Accounts

Is it more likely that Jesus was born in a barn or a cave? “Both” is the correct answer. He was born in a cave that had formerly used as a stable. These particulars assist us in reaching additional conclusions. First and foremost, in order to comprehend the Bible, we must attempt to strip away the 2,000 years of traditions that have built as we read the Bible from the perspective of our own culture and period. The images of the Christmas narrative that we have in our brains are muddled with imagery from medieval Europe, which is not surprising.

Rather of staying at a hotel or inn, they were most likely hosted by Joseph’s family in Bethlehem, where they were welcomed with open arms.

In fact, some academics think that Bethlehem was truly Joseph’s original home, and that he moved to Nazareth as a migrant laborer to find work in the towns that Herod was constructing across Galilee.

Matthew, Mary and the little child were in a dwelling.

Finally, while the real-life facts of life in Bethlehem may not correspond to the medieval stories that provide color to the delightful Christmas cards and songs that we enjoy, these elements do correspond completely to the descriptions in the gospels.

Dwight Longenecker is a Catholic priest who serves in the state of South Carolina, among other places.

Visitdwightlongenecker.com. Do you agree with the article? Please forward this to your friends! And don’t forget to join or start the conversation on our social media platforms! You may find us on social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, Parler, Instagram, MeWe, and Gab.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.