Where Did Mary Mother Of Jesus Die

Tomb of the Virgin Mary – Wikipedia

Church of the Sepulchre of Saint Mary, also known as the Tomb of the Virgin Mary, is a Christian tomb in the Kidron Valley, at the foot of the Mount of Olives, in Jerusalem, considered by Eastern Christians to be the burial place of Mary, Jesus’ mother. The tomb was built in the twelfth century. There is an agreement between religious congregations that has been in effect for 250 years that relates to the site.


Eastern Christianity’s Sacred Tradition teaches that the Virgin Mary died a natural death (theDormition of the Theotokos, or falling asleep), just like any other human being; that her soul was received by Christ upon death; and that her body was resurrected on the third day after her repose, at which time she was taken up, soul and body, intoheaven in anticipation of the general resurrection (theraphael).

According to one tradition, her grave was discovered to be empty on the third day.

In a speech delivered on June 25, 1997, Pope John Paul II stated that Mary had died naturally before being taken up into Heaven.

In response, Juvenal stated that on the third day following Mary’s burial, her tomb was discovered to be empty, with just her shroud remaining in the church of Gethsemane as a reminder of what had happened.

According to various traditions, it was theCincture of the Virgin Mary that was left behind in the tomb, or that she dropped herself during the Assumption of the Virgin Mary.


An archaeologist working for the Franciscan friars excavated the site in 1972. He discovered evidence of an ancient cemetery dating back to the 1st century; however, his findings have not yet been subjected to peer review by the wider archaeological community, and the validity of his dating has not been fully assessed. Following Bagatti’s interpretation of the remains, it appears that the cemetery’s original structure, which had three rooms (the real tomb being the inner chamber of the whole complex), was assessed in line with the conventions of the time period in question.

  1. On top of the grave, an edifice was constructed.
  2. Throughout the decades that followed, the church was demolished and rebuilt several times, but the crypt was preserved because it is believed to be the burial location of Prophet Isa’s mother, who is buried there (Jesus).
  3. Mary in the Valley of Jehoshaphat.
  4. The monastic structure was comprised of early Gothic columns, red-on-green paintings, and three towers that served as fortification.
  5. Despite the fact that this church was demolished by Saladin in 1187, the crypt was still preserved; all that remained were the south door and stairway, with the masonry from the upper church being used to construct the walls of Jerusalem.
  6. On Palm Sunday in 1757, the Greek Orthodox clergy seized control of a number of Holy Land sites, including this one, and evicted the Franciscans.

Throughout the centuries, the tomb has been held in trust by the Greek Orthodox Church of Jerusalem and the Armenian Apostolic Church of Jerusalem, while the grotto of Gethsemane has remained in the hands of the Franciscans.

The church

The rock-cut was created by The Tomb of Mary and its entrance, which is decorated with icons on its front side; the eastern apse of the crypt. There is now a glass encasement over the stone bench where the Virgin’s corpse was laid down. The cruciform chapel that protects the tomb has been dug in a rock-cut cave that was reached by a large descending stairway that dates back to the 12th century. It is preceded by a walled courtyard to the south. The chapel of Mary’s parents, Joachim and Anne, is located on the right side of the stairway (facing east).

  • There is a chapel dedicated to Saint Joseph, Mary’s husband, which was originally constructed as a mausoleum for two additional female relations of Baldwin II, and is located on the left (towards the west).
  • The eastapse is also home to the altars of the Greeks and Armenians.
  • At the moment, the Muslims no longer have ownership rights to this property.
  • Both the Armenian Patriarchate and the Armenian Apostolic Church of Jerusalem, as well as the Greek Orthodox Church of Jerusalem, are in control of the sanctuary.


According to a narrative that dates back to the 4th century AD and was first reported by Epiphanius of Salamis, Mary may have spent the last years of her life in the city of Ephesus, Turkey. This belief was inferred by the Ephesians from John’s presence in the city, as well as Jesus’ orders to John to look for Mary after his death. Epiphanius, on the other hand, pointed out that, while the Bible describes John departing for Asia, it makes no reference of Mary accompanying him on his journey. In accordance with the Eastern Orthodox Churchtradition, Virgin Mary lived in the vicinity of Ephesus, atSelçuk, where there is a place currently known astheHouse of the Virgin Maryand venerated by Catholics and Muslims, but argues that she only stayed there for a few years, despite accounts of her spending nine years there from the time of her birth until her death.

The Book of John on the Dormition of Mary, which was written in either the first, third, fourth, or seventh centuries, places her burial at Gethsemene, as does the Treatise on the Death of the Blessed Virgin Mary, which was published in the fourth century.

In later centuries, SaintsEpiphanius of Salamis, Gregory of Tours, Isidore of Seville, Modesto, Sophronius of Jerusalem, German of Constantinople, Andrew of Crete, and John of Damascusall speak of the tomb being in Jerusalem, and bear witness to the fact that this tradition was accepted by all the churches of the East and West.

Other claims

TurkmenKeraitesbelieve, in accordance with a Nestoriantradition, that another tomb of the Virgin Mary might be found inMary, Turkmenistan, a town that was formerly known as Mari. Other stories state that Jesus, after escaping the crucifixion, traveled to India with the Virgin Mary, where they lived until the end of their lives, according to the Bible. There is a belief within the Ahmadiyya movement that Mary was buried in the Pakistani town of Murree, and that her grave is currently housed at the shrine Mai Mari da Ashtan.

Another legend among the Christians of Nineveh in northern Iraq holds that the tomb of Mary is located in Erbil, with the location of the tomb being linked to the direction of tilt of the formerGreat Mosque of al-Nuriminaret inMosul, according to the tradition.

  • The crypt holding the tomb is reached through a staircase with 47 steps leading from the entryway. The lowest section of the entry stairwell
  • Saints Joachim and Anne Chapel, with icons of the two saints
  • A front decorated with symbols, as well as an entry door
  • The Tomb of Mary a front decorated with symbols, as well as an entry door
  • The Tomb of Mary The stone bench on which the Virgin’s corpse was laid down
  • The marble sarcophagus
  • And the marble sarcophagus. The western apse of the crypt has an image of Mary and Christ.

See also

  • The Abbey of Saint Mary in the Valley of Jehosaphat is located in the valley of Jehosaphat. The Feast of the Dormition of the Theotokos (according to Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Eastern Catholic traditions)
  • The Assumption of Mary (which is the same event as the Assumption of Mary, but is seen differently by Roman Catholic theology)
  • The Assumption of Mary (which is the same event as the Assumption of Mary, but is viewed differently by Roman Catholic theology)
  • House of the Virgin Mary, a Catholic shrine atop the Turkish mountain of Koressos


  1. What Should a Mother Do?’ at AmericanCatholic.org
  2. United Nations Conciliation Commission’ at United Nations (1949). Working Paper on the Holy Places prepared by the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine
  3. Cust, 1929, The Status Quo in the Holy Places prepared by the United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine On Wednesday, June 25, 1997, Pope John Paul II addressed a general audience
  4. Catholic Encyclopedia, The Tomb of the Blessed Virgin Mary
  5. Catholic Encyclopedia, The Holy Family
  6. Belt of the Holy Theotokos, by Father Demetrios Serfes, published on March 1, 1999, and archived from the original on January 31, 2010, retrieved on January 16, 2010
  7. Alviero Niccacci, “Archaeology, New Testament, and Early Christianity”Archived2012-10-23 at theWayback Machine, Studium Biblicum Franciscanum, Faculty of Biblical Sciences and Archaeology of the Pontifical University Antonianumin Rome
  8. Alviero Niccacci, “Archaeology, New Testament, and Early Christianity”Archived2012-10-23 at theWayback Machine, Studium Biblicum Franciscanum, Faculty of Biblical Sciences and Archaeology of the Work is still being done on the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (A Work in Progress)
  9. The Tomb of Mary
  10. Observe the rock-cut architecture
  11. The author Murphy-O’Connor (2008) writes on page 149 that In Helmut Koester’s Ephesos, Metropolis of Asia (2004), p.327, Vasiliki Limberis writes, “In two MMS. the author is said to be James the Lord’s brother
  12. In one, John Archbishop of Thessalonica, who lived in the seventh century.”
  13. AbHerbermann writes, “In two MMS. the author is said to be James the Lord’s brother
  14. In one, John Archbishop of The On September 27, 2006, the original version of this article was archived. Retrieved2014-08-01. The following is a CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link): Geary, 1878, page 88


  • Adomnán(1895). A pilgrimage to the Holy Land on Arculfus’s behalf (about the year A.D. 670). The Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society (aboutArculf, p.17)
  • Antoninus of Piacenza (aboutArculf, p.17)
  • And Antoninus of Piacenza (aboutArculf, p.17) (1890). The Holy Places visited by Antoninus Martyr about the year 570 A.D are listed below. Clermont-Ganneau, C.S., Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society, London, Palestine (1899). J. McFarlane’s translation of Archaeological Researches in Palestine, 1873-1874, from the French is available online. Vol. 1, London: Palestine Exploration Fund (pp. 20-21)
  • Cust, L.G.A. Vol. 1, London: Palestine Exploration Fund (pp. 20-21)
  • (1929). The current state of affairs in the Holy Places. High Commissioner of the Government of Palestine
  • Suzanne Olsson, H.M.S.O. for the High Commissioner of the Government of Palestine In Kashmir, Jesus was crucified. The Tomb of the Unknown (2019) | The claimed last burial location of Mary in Mari Ashtan, Pakistan, including images and further reference links
  • Fabri, F. (1896). Felix Fabri (approximately 1480–1483 A.D.) vol. I, part II, a collection of poems. Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society (pp.464-469)
  • Geary and Grattan (pp.464-469)
  • And others (1878). From Bombay to the Bosphorus, a voyage across Asiatic Turkey is recounted in this book. Sampson Low, Marston, SearleRivington, and C.G. Herbermann published Vol. 2 in London (1901). The Catholic Encyclopedia is a resource for learning about the Catholic faith. Encyclopedia Press
  • G. Le Strange, G. Le Strange, G. (1890). Palestine Under the Control of the Moslems: From A.D. 650 to 1500, a description of Syria and the Holy Land is given. Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund, London, OCLC1004386 (pp.210,219)
  • Maundrell, H., Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund, London, OCLC1004386 (pp.210,219)
  • Maundrell, H., Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund, London, OCLC1004386 ( (1703). A journey from Aleppo to Jerusalem during the Easter season in the year 1697. The Theatre Press in Oxford printed this edition. The Moudjir ed-dyn (p.102) is a fictional character created by the author (1876). Sauvaire is a French word that means “saved” (ed.). Histoire de Jérusalem et d’Hébron depuis Abraham jusqu’à la fin du XVe siècle de J.-C. : fragments de la Chronique de Moudjir-ed-dyn. (pp.27,33,193)
  • Murphy-O’Connor, J. Histoire de Jérusalem et d’Hébron depuis Abraham jusqu’à la fin du XVe siècle de J.- (2008). The Holy Land: An Oxford Archaeological Guide from the Earliest Times to the Year 1700 is a book on archaeology in the Holy Land. Oxford Archaeological Guides are published by Oxford University Press. Oxford University Press, p. 149, ISBN 978-0-19-923666-4. Oxford University Press. 2016-09-16
  • Retrieved 16 September 2016
  • J. Phokas, Phokas & Associates, Inc. (1889). Journey to the Holy Land on the Pilgrimage of Johannes Phocas. The Palestine Pilgrims’ Text Society (pp.20-21)
  • Pringle, Denys (pp.20-21)
  • Pringle, Denys (2007). The Churches of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem: The city of Jerusalem, Vol. III, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-0-521-39038-5 (pp.287-306)
  • Roberts, A. The Churches of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem: The city of Jerusalem, Vol. III, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-0-521-39038-5 (pp.287-306)
  • Roberts, A. The Churches of the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem (1886). The Twelve Patriarchs, Excerpts and Epistles, The Clementina, Apocrypha, Decretals, Memoirs of Edessa and Syriac documents, and Remains of the First Ages: Volume 8 of The Ante-Nicene Fathers: Translations of the Fathers’ Writings Down to A.D. 325: The Ante-Nicene Fathers: Translations of the Fathers’ Writings Down to A. Publishers: C. Scribner’s Sons
  • Vogüé, de
  • M. Vogüé (1860). Les églises de la Terre Sainte. (pp.305-313)
  • Warren, C.
  • Conder, C.R. Les églises de la Terre Sainte (1884). The Survey of Western Palestine: Jerusalem, London: Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund, (pp.40, 402)
  • The Survey of Western Palestine: Jerusalem, London: Committee of the Palestine Exploration Fund, (pp.40, 402)
See also:  What Color Robe Did The Romans Put On Jesus

External links

  • The Virgin Mary’s Tomb is located in Athens. Sacred Destinations gives a description of the interior and history of the site
  • Jerusalem provides a description of the inside and history of the site. Mary’s Tombat
  • Assumptions About Mary (comments on the historicity of the location) at Catholic Answers
  • O Svetoj zemlji, Jerusalimu I Sinajuat
  • O Svetoj zemlji, Je

The Virgin Mary’s Tomb is located in Athens, Greece. Holy Places gives an overview of the inside and history of the site; Jerusalem provides a description of the exterior and history of the place. Mary’s Tombat; Assumptions About Mary (comments on the historical accuracy of the site) at Catholic Answers; O Svetoj zemlji, Jerusalimu I Sinajuat; O Svetoj zemlji, Jerusalimu I Sinajuat; O Svetoj zemlji, Jerusalimu I Sinajuat; O Svetoj zemlji, Je

5 things to know about Mary, the mother of Jesus

It is definitely true that Mary, the mother of Jesus, is the most revered saint in the Christian faith. Despite this, we know very little about her. There is nothing in the New Testament that mentions her birth, death, physical appearance, or age. Aside from the stories of Jesus’ birth that are exclusively included in the gospels of Matthew and Luke, she is expressly referenced at just three other events in the life of her son, all of which take place after his birth. At a wedding when Jesus transforms water into wine, she makes an unsuccessful attempt to visit her son while he is teaching, and she witnesses his execution with her son.

So, here are five facts we do know about her that are worth sharing.

1. She was an accidental virgin

In the Gospel of Matthew, we are told for the first time that Mary was pregnant before she and Joseph had sexual relations. According to reports, she was “with child from the Holy Spirit.” Matthew used a prophesy from the Old Testament to demonstrate this point, stating that a “virgin will conceive and have a son, and the name of the child will be Emmanuel.” Matthew was referring to the Old Testament in its Greek translation. As a result, the original Hebrew term “almah” had been translated as “parthenos” in the Greek Old Testament, and from there into the Latin Bible as “virgo” and finally into English as “virgin.” Instead of just “young lady,” the Greek word “parthenos” refers to “a virgin intacta,” which indicates literally “a virgin who has not been defiled.” Briefly stated, Mary was referred to be a virgin due to a translation error in which the word “young lady” was rendered as “virgin.” Education of the Virgin by Guido Reni is a painting by Guido Reni.

Commons image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

2. She was a perpetual virgin

During and after the birth of Jesus, according to early Christian faith, Mary continued to be a virgin. This was likely only appropriate for someone who was referred to as “the mother of God” or “the God-bearer.” According to Saint Ambrose of Milan (c.339-97 CE), the doctrine of Mary’s perpetual virginity was ardently defended: “Blessed Mary is the gate, through which it is written that the Lord hath entered in by it; therefore, the gate shall be shut after birth; for, as a virgin, she both conceived and gave birth.” Several centuries later, the Lateran Synod of 649 CE, a council convened in Rome by the Western Church, made it an article of faith that Jesus was conceived “without seed” and that Mary “incorruptibly carried, her virginity being unaffected even after his birth.” All of this is happening despite the fact that the Gospels state that Jesus had siblings and sisters (Mark 3.32, Matthew 12.46, Luke 8.19).

Antonio Veneziano painted a tempera on panel picture of the Virgin and Child in 1380.

3. She was immaculately conceived

Since the time of Saint Ambrose, it has been widely acknowledged in Western theology that Mary never committed a sin. Was her sinlessness in this life, however, due to the fact that she was born without “original sin”? As a matter of fact, according to Western theology, each and every human being was born with original sin, which is considered to be the “genetic” result of the transgression of Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. Due to an increasing cult of devotion to the Virgin Mary during the medieval period, there were fine-grained theological disagreements on the subject.

It wasn’t until 1854 that the Catholic Church was able to fix the situation.

was maintained free from every taint of original sin, is a truth revealed by God and consequently one in which all the faithful should accept firmly and consistently.

4. She ascended into heaven

The early decades of the Christian tradition were deafeningly silent on the subject of Mary’s death. However, by the seventh and eighth centuries, the belief in the physical ascension of Mary into heaven had gained a solid foothold in both the Western and Eastern churches, and was widely accepted. More information may be found at: What may paradise be like, according to today’s essay? The Eastern Orthodox Greek Church adhered to the tradition of Mary’s death and burial. In accordance with this, Mary died in a natural way, and her soul was thereafter accepted by Christ.

She was then carried physically into the presence of God.

In 1950, the belief in Mary’s ascension into heaven was officially recognized as Catholic teaching.

The Assumption of the Virgin, painted by Luca Giordano in 1698, is a masterpiece. Commons image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

5. She is a sky goddess

When Mary was physically exalted into heaven, no bodily relics were left behind for us to venerate. Despite the presence of breast milk, tears, hair and nail clippings, the majority of her relics were of a “second order” nature, including clothing, jewelry, veils, and shoes. In the lack of her skeletal remains, her worshippers had to make do with visions — in Lourdes, Guadalupe, Fatima, Medjugorje, and other pilgrimage destinations. Her pilgrimage sites, like those of the other saints, were places where she might be summoned in order to beseech God to grant the requests of her followers.

In popular devotion, she was depicted as a sky deity who constantly wore blue clothing.

She was the goddess of the moon and the star of the sea, and she was worshipped as such.

Did the Virgin Mary die and, if so, where?

The year 1999 saw me traveling around Israel and the Holy Land, including a stop at the Basilica of the Dormition, where we were informed that the Virgin Mary had died. Years later, I traveled to Ephesus, where I stopped at a little house where we were informed Mary had lived and died. Saint Paul VI paid a visit to the residence in 1967, and Saint John Paul II delivered Mass there in 1979. My concern is this: Why hasn’t the church reached a judgment on the correct location of Mary’s death, given the historical significance of the issue?

  1. Theological conjecture has been a source of amusement for generations, and the church has never given a conclusive response to the topic.
  2. Some theologians believe that, because death is a result of sin, Mary would not have had to die if she had not committed sin.
  3. The topic of where Mary spent her final years on earth has been debated for centuries, but there are two solid historical traditions to consider.
  4. Other evidence, on the other hand, appears to indicate that Mary traveled to a location near Ephesus (modern-day Turkey) and remained there until she was taken up into heaven, under the protection of the apostle John.
  5. The validity of each tradition has never been explicitly determined by the church.
  6. The solution to your inquiry has been lost to the pages of history and is unlikely to be discovered again.
  7. You can reach Father Doyle at [email protected] with any inquiries.

retains ownership of the copyright. All intellectual property rights are retained. Creating links is welcomed, but it is not permitted to republish or re distribute without the publisher’s prior written consent. This includes framing or other similar methods of distribution.

When did Mary die? How did Mary die?

QuestionAnswer The last time Mary, the mother of Jesus, is mentioned in the Bible is when the Holy Spirit descended upon her (along with many others) on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:1–4). Following that, we don’t get to hear anything further about Mary in the Bible. The Bible says that Mary most likely spent her final years at John’s house (John 19:27), where she died. We don’t know exactly where John used to reside. He could have had a residence in either Jerusalem or Ephesus. Several scholars have proposed that, because it seems likely that John managed many of the churches in Asia Minor, Mary followed him to Ephesus, where she became a member of the Ephesian church, which Timothy served as pastor (1 Timothy 1:3).

  1. The year AD 43 and AD 48 are mentioned in two different traditions, but we have no method of authenticating either date.
  2. According to one tradition, Mary never lived in Ephesus, but rather in a modest stone home constructed over a spring on a hill on the road outside of Jerusalem, where she spent her days.
  3. According to folklore, Mary built monument stones marking the different stations of the cross beside her home to commemorate her life.
  4. She died there and was buried with the Holy Grail, which she had brought with her from France.
  5. Catherine Emmerich, a Catholic mystic who lived in the early 1800s, claimed to have had a vision in which she saw Mary’s dying minutes.

Catherine’s vision depicts the apostles’ presence at Mary’s deathbed, Peter’s administration of the Mass and extreme unction to Mary, Mary’s death (which occurred at the same hour as Jesus’ death), her spirit’s ascension into heaven (accompanied by many souls released from purgatory), her burial, and her body’s assumption the next night.

At the end of the day, we have to face the truth that we do not know anything about Mary’s latter life or her death.

Mary’s tale is subservient to the story of Christ, despite the fact that it is more than incidental to it. Questions about Biblical Characters Return to: Questions about Biblical Characters When did Mary pass away? What caused Mary’s death?

Where did Mary live after the Resurrection?

Christians believe that Jesus rose from the grave and ascended into heaven, according to the Scriptures. But what happened to his mother after that? While those sentences do not supply us with a specific address, they do present us with a number of hints. At the time of Jesus’ death, it is generally considered that his foster-father Joseph had already died, according to traditional accounts. As a result, Jesus would be the primary family member responsible for caring for his ailing mother. More information may be found at: Is it possible that Jesus and Joseph were true carpenters?

Jesus called out to his mother and the disciple whom he adored who were standing nearby, and he said to his mother, “Woman, see!

(See also John 19:26-27.) The majority of biblical experts agree that the “beloved disciple” was St.


Because it is documented in the book of Acts, it appears that John looked for her while she was in Jerusalem at the time. Once they reached Jerusalem from the mount called Olivet, which is a short distance away from the city and only one sabbath day’s journey away, they went up to the upper room, where they were staying: Peter and John, James and Andrew, Philip and Thomas, Bartholomew and Matthew, James the son of Alphaeus, Simon the Zealot and Judas the son of James. All of these people, together with the women and Mary the mother of Jesus, as well as his brothers and sisters, joined together in prayer.

The “Way of the Cross” was where Mary spent the remainder of her life, according to legend, walking it every day and repeating the steps taken by her son.

More information may be found at: Find out more about the grotto in Turkey where Saint Peter said Mass.

See also:  What Would Jesus

A second site in Jerusalem, known as the Church of the Dormition, is maintained by Benedictine monks and is dedicated to Mary, mother of Jesus.


On the other hand, there is a story that John the Evangelist was born in the city of Ephesus, which is supported by historical evidence. Numerous people think that because John resided in this location, the Virgin Mary also dwelt there with him and that her ascension to heaven occurred there as well. Some private visions of Blessed Anne Catherine Emmerich in the nineteenth century, which identified Ephesus as the location of the Virgin Mary’s home, served to further cement this conclusion. More information may be found at: In the ancient city of Ephesus, there are five Christian sites worth seeing.

Make sure to go through the slideshow below to learn about some of the earliest depictions of the Virgin Mary.

Did Virgin Mary Die Before Assumption?

Although the idea of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary into Heaven at the conclusion of her earthly life is not difficult to understand, one question is a frequent subject of controversy: Did Marydie do anything before she was accepted into Heaven, body and soul?

The Traditional Answer

From the earliest Christian traditions surrounding the Assumption, the response to the issue of whether the Blessed Virgin died in the same way that all men do has always been affirmative. Originally known as “the Dormition of the Most Holy Theotokos,” the feast of the Assumption was originally observed in the Christian East in the sixth century (the Mother of God). The traditions surrounding the Dormition continue to be based on a fourth-century manuscript known as “The Account of St. John the Theologian of the Falling Asleep of the Holy Mother of God,” which is followed by both Catholics and Orthodox Christians today.

The “Falling Asleep” of the Holy Mother of God

In that text, written in the voice of Saint John the Evangelist (to whom Christ had assigned the care of His mother while on the Cross), the Archangel Gabriel appears to Mary while she prays at the Holy Sepulchre, and she receives instructions from him (the tomb in which Christ had been laid onGood Friday, and from which He rose onEaster Sunday). The Archangel Gabriel informed the Blessed Virgin that her earthly existence had come to an end, and she made the decision to return to Bethlehem to be with her Savior.

Together, they transported her bed (again, with the assistance of the Holy Spirit) to her house in Jerusalem, where Christ appeared to her the following Sunday and instructed her not to be afraid.

She sprang up and kissed each of the apostles on the cheek with her own hand, and they all gave praise to God; then the Lord reached out His undefiled hands and accepted her pure and faultless soul.

The apostles carried Mary’s body on a couch to the Garden of Gethsemane, where they laid her remains in a new tomb, which they named after her: In the midst of this, an intoxicating fragrance of sweet savour poured forth from the sacred sepulchre of our Lady, the mother of God; and for three days, the voices of unseen angels could be heard praising Christ our God, who had been born of our Lady.

It is believed that Mary died before her body was taken up into Heaven, according to “The Falling Asleep of the Holy Mother of God,” which is the earliest existing written record chronicling the end of her life.

The Same Tradition, East and West

Some details of the Assumption are different in the earliest Latin versions of the story, which were written a couple of centuries later. However, they all agree that Mary died and that Christ received her soul; that the apostles entombed her body; and that Mary’s body was taken up into Heaven from the tomb. Whatever the case, it is important to note that none of these writings has the authority of Scripture; what is important is that they tell us what Christians in both the East and the West felt had happened to Mary at the end of her life.

(All of the documents agree that her body remained incorrupt from the time of her death and the time of her Assumption.)

Pius Xii on the Death and Assumption of Mary

However, whereas Eastern Christians have preserved the early traditions surrounding the Assumption, Western Christians have largely lost contact with these traditions. The expression “falling asleep” is used to characterize Mary’s Assumption in the Eastern tradition, leading some to believe that she was taken into Heaven before she died. InMunificentissimus Deus, his declaration of the dogma of the Assumption of Mary on November 1, 1950, Pope Pius XII cites ancient liturgical texts from both East and West, as well as the writings of Church Fathers, all of which indicate that the Blessed Virgin had died before her body was taken up into Heaven.

Mary’s Death Is Not a Matter of Faith

The doctrine, as articulated by Pope Pius XII, does not definitively answer whether the Virgin Mary died on the cross. That the Immaculate Mother of God, the eternally Virgin Mary, had fulfilled the course of her earthly existence and had been assumed body and soul into heavenly glory is what Catholics must believe is what they must believe. The phrase “having fulfilled the course of her earthly existence” is unclear; it leaves up the possibility that Mary did not die prior to her Assumption of the Virgin Mary.

Where Is Mary Buried?

We are not going to make you wait for an answer to come in. Mary, the Mother of God, is not commemorated in any way. Instead, the following is what transpired. In the course of her earthly existence, the Immaculate Mother of God, the eternally Virgin Mary, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory, as stated in the Bible. When Pope Pius XII issued the encyclicalMunificentissimus Deus in 1950, he formally declared the Assumption of Mary to be a doctrine of the Catholic Church, which was officially recognized as such the following year.

In order for Catholics to comprehend the reasons behind the dogmas, not just on the level of apologetics, but also on a very personal level, it is essential that they do so.

There are significant ramifications to the Assumption of Mary since it demonstrates not just Mary’s character but also God’s character. “The Assumption of the Virgin” by Titian is a masterpiece.

Scriptural Objection

A recurrent charge leveled against the Catholic Church is that different popes “create” new dogmas. The allegation of “invention” is frequently leveled because there is no explicit Scriptural event to support it. The fact that Mary’s Assumption is not clearly described as a historical occurrence in the Gospel of Matthew is correct. For many individuals, this is the end of the story. In the Protestant tradition, many people are cautious, if not contemptuous, of any theological position that is not explicitly stated in Scripture, according to the belief (” sola Scriptura “), which holds that there can be no theological certainty apart from the written Gospel.

  • As Bishop Fulton Sheen reminds us, “The Church had already spread over the entire Roman Empire before a single book of the New Testament had been composed.” There were already a large number of martyrs in the Church long before the Gospels or the Epistles were written.
  • —Fulton Sheen, The World’s First Love But, if Mary had been taken up into Heaven, it is very certain that the event would have been recorded in Scripture, isn’t it?
  • Sacred Scripture does not operate in this manner, which can be frustrating.
  • Many of the deeds of the Apostles—including those of Mary, Queen of the Apostles—have gone undocumented for a variety of reasons.
  • In Christ’s private existence, he remained exactly that: private.
  • Are we, on the other hand, willing to assert that nothing significant occurred over these three decades?
  • Even in the context of His public existence, not everything that Jesus did was recorded in the Scriptures.
  • (Even the longest Gospel may be read in approximately an hour and fifteen minutes.) In no way does Scripture claim to offer an entire account of every aspect of Christ’s life; rather, it does not make the claim that it does so.
  • Is it reasonable to expect all of Jesus’ actions to be recorded in Scripture if many of his actions are not recorded in Scripture?
  • For the sake of Sheen’s argument, many early Christians acted on the basis of direct talks and interactions with Christ, and/or people who genuinely interacted with Christ.

This leads to a number of extremely fascinating questions when it comes to the Assumption of Mary, which we will explore further below.

Historical Invention?

On the other hand, there are many who argue that the Assumption was invented by Pope Pius XII in 1950, rather than on biblical basis. They argue that the entire concept was taken out of thin air by the pope. Was that the case? Despite the fact that it is a magnificent text in its own right,Munificentissimus Deus expressed something that Catholics already believed—and had believed for a long time before it was published. Even if you had asked a Catholic in 1940 if the Catholic Church taught the dogma of the Assumption, he would almost certainly have replied in the yes, according to historical evidence.

  • Catholics have already been praying the Assumption as one of the Glorious Mysteries of the Rosary for centuries by the time of Pope Pius XII in 1950.
  • Titian’s The Assumption of the Virginin 1516, Correggio’sAssumption of the Virginin 1522, and Rubens’Assumption of the Virgin Maryin 1626 were among the works showing Mary’s Assumption.
  • By 1950, old Catholic churches all over the world had been named in honor of Mary’s Assumption, which was celebrated on August 15th.
  • For example, Dr.
  • Considering the old Christian maxim, lex orandi, lex credendi, this is not a trivial problem to raise at this stage (the law of worship is the law of belief).

Theological Questions, or Lack of Questions

Saint John Damascene, who lived in the early eighth century, proposed a logical explanation for why Mary was accepted into Heaven. He explains himself as follows: “Even after death, it was only fair that she, who had maintained her virginity during delivery, should maintain her own body free of any defilement as well. That she should live in the holy tabernacles was only right because she had cradled the Creator in her womb like a child at her breast.” —St. John Damascene, a.k.a. When challenged about Mary’s Assumption, opponents claim that there is no scriptural proof for it.

As an example, Saint Albert the Great (1200-1280) advocated the theory that Mary, as the “New Eve,” was immune from Eve’s fourfold curse mentioned in the third chapter of Genesis since she was the “New Adam.” “It is clear from these evidence and authority, as well as from many more, that the most holy Mother of God has been elevated above the choirs of angels,” says Saint Albert.

There are several Christian theologians who have unwaveringly believed in Mary’s Assumption and have written in support of that doctrine, which can be traced back over a long period of ecclesiastical history and are quite easy to find.

What is really difficult is locating Christian theologians who have refused to embrace it, or who have ever expressed opposition to it in the first place.

Habeas Corpus

Whenever non-Christians dismiss the concept of Christ’s resurrection, Biblical academics frequently answer by posing the question, “What happened to Christ’s body?” It’s a reasonable question. Even if one excludes from consideration the possibility of the Resurrection, there are only a few alternatives (his enemies took the corpse, his friends stole the body, Jesus staged his death), and none of them make much sense. Moreover, as some Biblical scholars have observed, if his opponents took the corpse, why not just produce it and use it as the most powerful conceivable proof against the reality of Christianity?

  • If Jesus had pretended to die, he would have required the soldiers to be in on the plot as well, which they were not.
  • Furthermore, you can only fake your death for a certain period of time before you are confronted with a genuine death that cannot be faked.
  • Those who do not believe in Mary’s assumption might be interested in hearing our responses.
  • If yes, what is the reason behind this?
  • What’s the deal with hers?
  • The remains of saints were revered by Christians, and when they did so, the bodies were taken to a secure place: the Roman catacombs, which are still in existence today.
  • The grave would have been marked with Mary’s name, and it would have been known to practically every Christian on the face of the planet.
See also:  Where Exactly Did Jesus Get Crucified?

The Assumption of the Virgin Mary (Rubens) /Rolf Kranz, original work licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

“However, as Pope Pius XII points out, the Church has never sought for or suggested the devotion of the Blessed Virgin’s corporeal relics to the general public.” That’s a reality that ought to be considered.

It is extremely advised that every church altar be embellished with an embedded first-class relic of great importance.

But it is true.

That would be an exceedingly strange answer from a Christian, unless, of course, they thought that Mary’s corpse had already been taken up to the heavenly realm.

They are quite ornate and feature a large number of religious artifacts, icons, and censors.

Every claimant says that was the final spot she fell asleep or died for a brief period before being assumed body and soul into the presence of the Almighty.

Catholics, on the other hand, are under no obligation to be interested or to wonder. We believe that Mary’s body and soul are in the presence of her holy Son in the presence of the angels in heaven.


In the Catholic community, the Assumption of Mary is a source of tremendous happiness. Bishop Fulton Sheen writes in his book, The World’s First Love, that the world is in the throes of despair, but that the Church has an answer. “The Mystical Body of Christ urges the hopeless to reflect on the two most terrible wounds the planet has ever received: the empty tomb of Christ and the empty tomb of Mary,” he says in his book. It is our Catholic faith that the image of the empty tomb should inspire hope and excitement in our hearts and minds.

  • Images: Death and Assumption of the Virgin by Fernando Yáez de la Almedina (public domain), through Wikimedia Commons; Death and Assumption of the Virgin by Fernando Yáez de la Almedina (public domain), via Wikimedia Commons Additionally, check out 5 Historical Proofs of Jesus’ Resurrection.
  • What happened to the early Christians after the Resurrection?
  • John Clark is a published novelist as well as a speechwriter.
  • was his debut novel.
  • He has published hundreds of articles and blogs about Catholic family life and apologetics, which have appeared in publications such as Magis Center, Seton Magazine, Catholic Digest, and Homiletic and Pastoral Review, among others.


Known as St. Mary or the Virgin Mary, she has been honored in the Christian church since the apostolic age and has been a popular topic in Western art, music, and literature from the beginning of the Christian era. She is the mother of Jesus. Mary is well-known through scriptural allusions, which, nevertheless, are insufficient to create a comprehensive biography of her life and times. Through the names that have been given to Mary throughout the history of Christiancommunities—guarantee of the Incarnation, virgin mother, secondEve, mother of God, eternally virgin and immaculate, and assumed intoheaven—we may trace the evolution of the concept of Mary.

Her humility and adherence to God’s word, as recorded in the New Testament, have elevated her to the status of a model for Christians of all eras.

The other name for the artwork refers to the fact that it was once housed at a monastery of the Poor Clares order in Poligny, Burgundy, France. AlkaliSoaps provided the photography. The Rogers Fund was established by the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City in 1933. (33.23)

Biblical references

The story of the Annunciation, which reports that she was living in Nazarethand was betrothed to Joseph(Luke 1:26 ff.), is the first and last time that Mary is mentioned in the Bible, and the last time she is mentioned (Acts of the Apostles 1:14), she is included in the company of those who devoted themselves to prayer after Jesus’ ascension into heaven (Acts of the Apostles 1:14). According to the Gospels, she occurs in the following incidents: Among the events recorded are the Annunciation, the visit with Elizabeth, her kinswoman and the mother of John the Baptist, the forerunner of Jesus (Luke 1:39 ff.), the birth of Jesus and his presentation in the Temple (Luke 2:1 ff.), the visit to Jerusalem by the Magi and the flight to Egypt (Matthew 2:1 ff.), the marriage at Cana in Galilee, although her name is not mentioned (Mark 2:1 ff) (John 19:26 ff.).

No matter how closely one considers these incidents to be accurate historical descriptions, they do not add up to a cohesive portrayal of Mary.

However, since the beginning of Christian history, the concepts that these images represent have served as a starting point for discussion and devotion on the Virgin Mary.

As a result, a historical study of that evolution also serves as an introduction to the current condition of Christian theology regarding Mary to a significant degree.

Dogmatic titles

The phrase “born of woman” in Galatians 4:4, which was written before any of the Gospels, is perhaps the oldest mention to Mary in Christian literature. As analogies in the Bible such as Job 14:1 and Matthew 11:11 reveal, the term is a Hebraic manner of referring about a person’s fundamental humanity. The phrase “born of woman” was intended to assert that Jesus was a genuine man, in opposition to the attempt—later seen in various systems of gnosticism, an early 2nd-century dualistic religion—to deny that he had lived a fully human life; in fact, some gnostics believe that he passed through the body of Mary in the same way that light passes through a window.

As a result, the term designated Mary as the indication or promise that the Son of God had indeed been born in the form of a human being.

Some academics have even asserted that the key connotation of the term “born of the Virgin Mary” in theApostles’ Creed was the church’s insistence on Jesus’ genuine manhood, which they believe was the primary meaning of the phrase.

Any other obligations that have been entrusted to her in devotion and indogma take precedence over her mothering responsibilities.

In most cases, those who support the virgin birth contend that the possibility of real humanity was made possible when the Virgin Mary accepted her commission as a guarantee of the Incarnation (Luke 1:38): “Let it be with me according to your word.” Although the titleco-redemptrix has come to denote a more active role by Mary in the redemption of humankind, the precise nature of this participation is still a source of debate among Catholic theologians.

This is the origin of the titleco-redemptrix, which indicates some participation with Christ in the redemption of humankind and has been assigned to Mary in Roman Catholic theology.

Joseph, Mary, and the infant Jesus are shown in a stained glass window.

Both accounts make a point of asserting that Jesus was conceived in the womb of Mary without the intervention of any human being (Matthew 1:18 f.; Luke 1:34 f.), but the numerous textual variants in Matthew 1:16, some of which contain the words “Joseph begat Jesus,” have led some scholars to question whether such an assertion was part of Matthew’s original account.

Although it is not mentioned by the Apostle Paul, TheGospel According to Markbegins with Jesus as an adult, and TheGospel According to John, which begins with his prehistorical existence, makes no mention of the virgin birth, unless the variant of John 1:13 that reads “.who was born” rather than “.who were born” is used to support the virgin birth.

The disputes about Mary’s virginity have dominated postbiblical Christian writing, with the majority of the literature devoted to her being written after her death.

When it comes to understanding Jesus Christ and his life and work in the New Testament, one of the most common interpretations is the drawing of parallels between him andAdam: “because as all died in Adam, so all will be brought alive in Christ” (1 Corinthians15:22).

Whatever your opinion on whether or not the tale of The Annunciation in the first chapter of The Gospel is true, According to Luke, this was originally intended to illustrate a comparable comparison between Eve and Mary, but it quickly became a focus of Christian thought.

Irenaeus elaborated on the parallel between Eve, who had disobeyed the word of God while she was a virgin, and Mary, who had obeyed it while she was also a virgin: for Adam had to be restored in Christ in order for mortality to be absorbed in immortality, and Eve in Mary in order for a virgin, who had become the advocate of a virgin, should undo and destroy virgin Irenaeus did not discuss the matter; he appears to have taken the comparison for granted, which may imply that it was not his own creation but rather a product of tradition, for which he held a high level of regard.

According to whatever interpretation one chooses, the parallel ascribes to Mary and her obedience a significant role in the redemption of the human race: all died in Adam, but Eve had participated in the sin that brought about their deaths; all were saved in Christ, but Mary had participated in the life that made this possible.

During the 4th century, the title appears to have arose in devotional usage, most likely in Alexandria, and appears to have been drawn as a logical deduction from the doctrine of Christ’s full deity, which had been established as a dogma during that time period, and those who defended that dogma were also those who made the deduction.

  1. Towards the end of the 4th century, the Theotokos had established herself in a number of different sectors of the church with great success.
  2. Nestorius’ arguments, along with other parts of his doctrine, were rejected by the Council of Ephesus in 431.
  3. When it reads “born of the Virgin Mary,” the Apostles’ Creed appears to be teaching at the very least thevirginitas in partu.
  4. With the rise of theasceticideal activity in the church, this concept of Mary as a model of the ever-virgin was given more credence.
  5. Old Testament texts used in favor of the doctrine by Church Fathers (such as Ezekiel 44:2 and Song of Solomon 4:12) were probably only convincing to those who already believed in it.
  6. The great theologian and bishop of northern Africa, St.
  7. 44.1 x 32 centimeters Baltimore’s Walters Art Museum is a must-see.
  8. I do not plan to raise a single question on the issue of sin, out of reverence for the Lord and my fellow man.

In the end, it was Augustine’s distinction between original sin (which is the sin that all people are born with) and actual sin (which is the sin that people commit during their lives), which was firmly established in Western theology, that compelled a further clarification of what it meant to be sinless in Mary’s case.

Was she, however, exempt from the penalty of original sin?

As the most important medievaltheologian in Western history has taught, her conception was tainted, as was the conception of all humans, but that God suppressed and ultimately extinguished original sin in her before she was born, a position that is representative of the position taken by St.

The idea of theImmaculate Conception, which was developed by Duns Scotus, a 13th-century British Scholastic theologian, and subsequently declared as Roman Catholic dogma by Pope Pius IX in 1854, was in opposition to this stance.

Luke, in the Benedictine monastery of Santa Mara de Montserrat, Catalonia, Spain.

DREAMSTIME.COM is a project of Martinmates.

When the Proclamation of the Immaculate Conception was issued, petitions began to arrive at the Vatican requesting a definition of the Assumption of the Virgin into Heaven, which was believed by Roman Catholics and celebrated on the Feast of the Assumption.

However, despite the fact that over eight million people signed such petitions over the course of the following century, Rome remained hesitant because it found it impossible to articulate the teaching in light of Scripture and early witnesses of Christian tradition.

Such reasons from silence, on the other hand, were insufficient to establish a dogma, and, on the plus side, even the oldest doctrinal and liturgical witness in favour of the notion had emerged rather late in historical development.

Petersburg, features cherubs accompanying Mary. Images of Fine Art/Images of Cultural Heritage

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.