Where Is Golgotha, Where Jesus Was Crucified?
Is it possible that the Church of the Redeemer has the answer? Employees of the Biblical Archaeology Society, October 26, 202120 Comments150629 views What evidence is there to suggest that the Church of the Holy Sepulchre is the real site of Golgotha, where Jesus was crucified, based on the Church of the Redeemer (as depicted here)? What is the current location of Golgotha in Jerusalem? It was Golgotha, according to the New Testament, that served as the place of Jesus’ crucifixion and execution.
It was in the May/June 2016 edition of Biblical Archaeology Review when Marcel Serr and Dieter Vieweger discussed their Archaeological Views column, entitled “Golgotha: Is the Holy Sepulchre Church Authentic?” They discussed historical and contemporary research into the place whereJesuswas crucified.
The precise site of Jesus’ crucifixion is a matter of debate.
The Church of the Holy Sepulchre is located in Jerusalem.
- In line with Roman and Jewish traditions at the time, Golgotha would have had to be positioned outside of the city limits of Jerusalem.
- So, where exactly is Golgotha situated?
- When the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the traditional location of Jesus’ crucifixion, was erected in the fourth century C.E., was it built within or outside the city walls of Jerusalem?
- Leen Ritmeyer created the illustration.
Attempts to locate a so-called Second Wall south of the Holy Sepulchre Church that had served as the northern wall of Jerusalem during Jesus’ time (and would have moved the site of the church outside of Jerusalem during Jesus’ time) have proven fruitless—although Josephus, the knowledgeable first-century Jewish historian, does mention such a wall (The Jewish War5.146).
For over a century, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, which is built at Golgotha, the site of Jesus’ crucifixion, appeared to provide a solution to the dilemma of authenticity.
Our website, blog and email newsletter are a crucial part ofBiblical Archaeology Society ‘s nonprofit educational mission
If you’d like to contribute to making Bible History Daily, BiblicalArchaeology.org, and our daily newsletter possible, please consider making a donation. Even a small donation of $5 is appreciated: According to Ute Wagner-Lux of the German Protestant Institute of Archaeology in Jerusalem, who dug under the Church of the Redeemer in 1970, this wall could not have been the Second Wall. She concluded that this wall could not have been the Second Wall. Why? In the words of Serr and Vieweger, “this wall was just five feet thick—far too small to be used as a city wall.” As a result, the search was restarted.
There are some hints from the Church of the Redeemer that the Church of the Holy Sepulchre is located outside the mysterious Second Wall, according to the findings of the excavations.
– Members of the BAS Library: Learn more about Golgotha and the Holy Sepulchre Church in the entire Archaeological Views column by Marcel Serr and Dieter Vieweger in the May/June 2016 edition of Biblical Archaeology Review.
Become a member of the BAS Library now.
Related reading in Bible History Daily:
The tour takes visitors through the ruins of Herod’s Jerusalem Palace, which may have served as the site of Jesus’ trial. The Terra Sancta Museum is a new stop on the Via Dolorosa that is open to the public. And Why It Really Does Make a Difference The “Strange” Ending of the Gospel of Mark and Why It Really Does Make a Difference What Day Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? During their journey to Byzantine Jerusalem, the pilgrims stop at the National Geographic Museum, where they may virtually see Jesus’ tomb.
Dig deeper into biblical Archaeology with your All-Access Membership
The universe of the Bible may be comprehended. Modern discoveries that give us with clues about the culture in which the ancient Israelites, and subsequently Jesus and the Apostles, lived allow us to get a better understanding of that civilization. The Biblical Archaeology Review serves as a guide on this interesting trip through time. Here is your invitation to come along with us as we learn more and more about the biblical world and its inhabitants. Each issue of Biblical Archaeology Review has papers that are richly illustrated and easy to read, such as the following: Discoveries from the time periods of the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament are fascinating.
Book reviews of the most recent publications in biblical archaeology The BAS Digital Library contains the following resources: The Biblical Archaeology Review has been published for more than 45 years.
8 years of archaeology experience Odyssey online, a scientific and interesting exploration of the ancient foundations of the Western world, is available at http://www.odysseyonline.com/.
Experts from across the world deliver video lectures.
By studying biblical archaeology, you may learn more about the Bible. The All-Access membership pass allows you to do just that.
Where did Jesus die? Where was Jesus crucified? — Place of a Skull
I’m becoming increasingly perplexed by the word Zion. Whether or whether this is the mountain on where Jesus was crucified is something I’d want to know.
All four gospels claim that Jesus was crucified on a hill calledGolgotha, often known as the “Place of the Skull,” across from Jerusalem. In some ways, the location where He died resembled a skull. It is stated in both John 19:20 and Hebrews 13:12 that the location of His crucifixion was outside of the city; rather, it was “near the city.” But where did Jesus die, exactly? What was the location of Jesus’ crucifixion?
Where Did Jesus Die? — Golgotha — Place of the Skull
When it comes to the site where Christ was crucified, the New Testament has five passages that mention it. Among the Scripture texts are Matthew 27.33, Mark 15:21-22, Luke 23.33, John 19:17, and Hebrews 13:12. And when they arrived at a location known as Golgotha, which literally translates as “Place of the Skull. They enlisted the help of a passerby who had just arrived from the countryside, Simon of Cyrene (the father of Alexander and Rufus), to bore His cross. Matthew 27:33 (NASB) Later, the soldiers led him to the location known as Golgotha, which means “Place of the Skull.” NASB)When they arrived at the location known as The Skull, they crucified Him as well as the criminals, one on the right and the other on the left.
Luke 23:33 (NASB) Jesus likewise suffered outside the gate in order that He may purify the people with His own blood, according to John 19:17 of the New International Version.
According to John 19:17, Golgotha is a Hebrew term that literally translates as “skull.” The Greek word kranion literally translates as “Calvary.” It is believed by some that the Church of the Holy Sepulcher was erected on the site of Golgotha, also known as “the Place of the Skull.” According to Luke 23:33, ” The Skull ” was the location where Jesus was crucified.
Essentially, this indicates that there was once a route that connected the countryside to Jerusalem.
What was the location of Jesus’ death?
He died outside of the city, on a hill known as The Place of a Skull, sometimes known as Golgotha, near a route heading from the countryside.
Where Christ Was Crucified — Calvary
Gordon’s Calvary is marked by the presence of a skull lodged in the side of a hill. Golgotha is supposed to be the hill on where the Crucifixion occurred. It is referred to as Calvary by Christians.
In Christianity, there is a hymn called “I Believe In A Hill Called Mount Calvary” that some Christians like to sing. On the summit of this hill, according to legend, Jesus was crucified, and this is where the Church of the Holy Sepulcher has been constructed.
On a hill known as “The Skull,” Jesus was crucified on a “old rough cross.” He gave his life there for you and me. He died so that our sins might be forgiven, so that we may be at peace with God, and so that we could one day spend eternity with God. If you are looking for God, you can find Him and enjoy eternal life if you search diligently. You must, however, go in quest of Him. When you find Him, you will be blessed with a personal connection with God as well as an abundant life.
I’m on the lookout for God. What is the importance of the cross that Jesus Christ carried on the crucifixion of Calvary? Did Jesus’ physical body and spiritual spirit perish? Is there any historical information available regarding the cross? Is it possible that Jesus was crucified in order to fulfill an ancient prophecy? Is there any historical information available regarding the cross? Is it possible that God was not present for three days? – Following the CrucifixionWhy would God allow His Son to suffer and die in our place?
Accounts of Christ’s Resurrection – The Resurrection of Christ
Where Did Jesus Die?
In case you’ve ever been to (or taught) Sunday School, chances are you’ve heard the following question dozens of times: “Where did Jesus die?” If you ask certain folks, they’ll tell you that it’s “the location of the skull.” Others have used the words “Calvary” or “Golgotha.” Both of these names refer to the location where Jesus died on the crucifixion on Good Friday, more than two thousand years ago.
In the Bible, this location had a significantly higher historical significance than it does now, and it was not picked at random.
What was the location of Jesus’ death?
Here’s where you can get your FREE Holy Week Guide.
What Does Golgotha Mean?
The term “Golgotha” refers to “the location of the skull.” This hill, which was positioned just outside the city’s walls and was appropriately named, was the site of executions for offenders (Matthew 27:33,Mark 15:22,John 19:17). In the words of Bible Study Tools, “It was a little knoll that was rounded in the shape of a naked skull.” Clearly, it was a well-known location outside the gate (Compare Hebrews 13:12), close to the city (Luke 23:26), with a “garden” (John 19:41), and on a thoroughfare going into the country, as indicated by the evangelists.
The hillside above Jeremiah’s Grotto, located to the north of the city, is most likely the real location of Calvary, according to historical evidence.
Thankfully, Jesus was buried in a tomb with due honors, but we can’t say the same for the two robbers who flanked him on the cross, who were likely beheaded.
What Does the Bible Say about Golgotha?
The name “Golgotha” appears in three of the four Gospel narratives. Here is a peek at what each individual has to say about this dangerous location. “They arrived to a spot named Golgotha (which literally translates as “the place of the skull”),” Matthew 27:33 says. The word skull comes on the screen once more. If archeologists are correct in their assumption, the rock formation on this hill resembles the shape of a skull. Furthermore, one cannot overlook the obvious death overtones of this location, which has real skulls that have decayed and decomposed.
- If it had gained notoriety, or in this case, infamy, as a result of a moniker given to it by adjacent Jerusalem residents, it had achieved renown.
- The Israelite people all spoke the same language, which was Aramaic.
- Additionally, the fact that all three Gospels indicate the same spot of Christ’s death might be a source of hope.
- Eventually, his torture wounds have caused him to lose his ability to heave it.
Where Is Golgotha?
Apart from the imprecise “outside the gates of Jerusalem,” archeologists have a very good idea of where the tomb is located, despite the fact that we don’t know where it is. It has been reduced down to two candidates, according to Grace Communion International: According to the latest available data, just two have been judged worthy of serious consideration.” Traditional location is inside the area presently occupied by the Church of the Holy Sepulchre (at right), which is located in the Christian Quarter of Jerusalem’s Old City (see map below) (see map below).
The other potential site is a rocky hill known as Gordon’s Calvary, which is located immediately north of Jerusalem’s Old City.” According to legend, the anointing stone, which was used to prepare Jesus’ body for burial, may be found in the former, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.
During non-pandemic periods, travelers can pay a visit to both locations where it is possible that Jesus walked and even died for the sins of humanity.
The Resurrection of Jesus, rather than his death, is the focal point of Christian belief. After all, the angel proclaims at the place of Jesus’ burial, “He is not present.” “He has resurrected from the dead!”
When Did Jesus Die?
Jesus died at 3 p.m. on the cross of Calvary (or 15:00). As a result of his terrible injuries, he died very quickly on the cross after spending the previous night on trial for crimes he did not commit. He had had no sleep, had sweat blood even before the torture began, and had died very swiftly on the trial. When Jesus died so suddenly, even Pilate was taken aback, as recorded in Mark 15. Usually, in order to expedite the process of death (particularly during a festival like Passover), Roman guards would break the legs of individuals who were hanging on the cross.
However, when the Romans arrived at Jesus’ location, they learned that he had already died.
The fact that Jesus died before the Romans were able to capture him fulfilled the prophesy that his bones would not shatter (Psalm 34:20) when he died.
3 Facts You May Not Know about Where Jesus Died
Now that we’ve established some of the facts regarding Golgotha, let’s move on to some information about Calvary that many people aren’t aware of. At first glance it appears that Golgotha is synonymous with Mt. Moriah, the location where Abraham comes close to sacrificing his son. Despite the fact that there is little archeological evidence to corroborate this, Christians cannot help but get enthusiastic about the possibility of parallelism between the two stories. After all, God commands Abraham to offer up his only son as a sacrifice (Genesis 22).
- In contrast, God does not send a scapegoat for the death of his own Son, Jesus, as he did in the case of the crucifixion.
- Second, the wordCalvary, which meaning skull in both Latin and English, is used.
- However, it was not until the 1700s that the word first appeared in English.
- For many years, Roman authorities executed criminals, frequently zealots and insurrectionists, to serve as a warning to Israelites not to tamper with them or attempt any uprisings against them.
- Not only did those who were crucified have to endure a torturous death, but they also had to contend with humiliating accusations from those who passed by.
- Fortunately, Jesus does not remain at Golgotha or elsewhere in the surrounding area.
- After the 40-day celebration of the Feast of the Three Kings, he ascends into Heaven.
He provides us reason to be hopeful after Golgotha.
Photograph courtesy of Getty Images/azerberber She is a multi-published author and a graduate of the professional writing program at Taylor University, where she studied creative writing.
As a writer and editor, she has worked for a number of different publishing firms as well as periodicals, newspapers, and literary agencies, and she has worked with writers such as Jerry B.
Her modern-day Daniel trilogy, published by IlluminateYA, is now available.
Her inspirational adult novel Picture Imperfect, which will be released in November of 2021, will also be released.
Located inside our broader Holy Week and Easter resource collection, this page is focussed on the events leading up to and following the death and resurrection of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.
What is Lent, and why is it observed each year?
What Is the Meaning of Palm Sunday?
What is the significance of Good Friday?
Easter Greetings and Prayers At Easter, the Son of God took on the sins of the world and beat the devil, death, and the grave in a single battle.
It is through the characters in The Characters of Easter that you will become familiar with the unusual group of regular people who were present to witness the mystery of Christ’s death and resurrection.
As a devotional or study for both individuals and groups, this FREE audio offers a fresh perspective on the Lenten season. It is available for download now.
Where Was Jesus Crucified?
The crucifixion and resurrection of Jesus determine whether or not the Christian religion is valid. Understanding God’s pardon, everlasting life, and the hope we have in Christ are all built on these two historical events, which are interconnected. The faith is jeopardized if these events do not take place. However, while speaking about Christ’s resurrection, the apostle Paul emphasizes the following point: “But since it is taught that Christ has been raised from the dead, how can any of you argue that there is no resurrection of the dead?” Even if there is no resurrection of the dead, it is unlikely that Christ has been risen from the grave.
These events did in fact take place, and there is a substantial amount of extra-biblical evidence to support this claim.
What Scripture tells us about the crucifixion
Because of Jesus’ crucifixion and resurrection, the Christian faith is either confirmed or denied. God’s pardon, eternal life, and the hope we have in Christ are all understood in part because of these two historical occurrences. The faith is jeopardized if these things do not occur. However, while speaking about Christ’s resurrection, the apostle Paul makes the following point: “But since it is taught that Christ has been raised from the dead, how can any of you argue that there is no resurrection of the dead?” No one, not even Christ, has been risen if the dead do not rise from the grave.
It is undeniable that these events took place, and there is a substantial amount of extrabiblical evidence to support this claim.
The Church of the Holy Sepulchre
It is at this location, in the northwest sector of Jerusalem’s ancient city, that the Church of the Holy Sepulchre is located, which is one of the earliest acknowledged locations for Jesus’ crucifixion. After the storming of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Temple in A.D. 70, the city was transformed into a Roman colony, and its name was changed to Aelia Capitolina (Capital of the Capitol). During her journey to Aelia Capitolina, Empress Helena (Constantine’s mother) is said to have discovered a temple to Venus built over the “recognized” location of Jesus’ burial, according to legend.
They were able to select “the real cross” because of a miracle cure that occurred in connection with one of the three crosses.
It has become a must-see pilgrimage destination for many Christians of many denominations and traditions.
There appear to be some big issues with it, to put it mildly.
It appears that Jesus was crucified outside the city according to the Bible when we look at the text: Due to the fact that the site of Jesus’ crucifixion was close to the city and that the sign was written in three languages (Aramaic, Latin, and Greek), a large number of Jews were able to read it (John 19:20, emphasis added).
Likewise, Christ suffered outside the city gate in order to make the people holy via his own blood.
Let us then approach him outside the camp, carrying the dishonor he has endured in his life. In this place, we do not have an enduring city, but we are yearning for the city that is yet to be built (Hebrews 13:11–14, emphasis mine).
Gordon’s Calvary (Skull Hill)
Many evangelical Christians choose a rocky outcrop north of Jerusalem’s Damascus Gate, which is located north of the Old City. This bald hilltop first came to public attention in the 19th century, when a German theologian by the name of Edward Robinson proposed it as a possible location for a religious site, according to our research. This viewpoint was adopted by Charles Gordon, a well-known British major general, in the late 1800s, and it became linked with him as a result. In what ways does it stand out as a possible place for the crucifixion?
- This helps to make sense of Mark’s words: “Some ladies were standing nearby, keeping an eye on everything.” Mary Magdalene, Mary the mother of James the younger and of Joseph, and Salome were among those who were present” (Mark 15:40).
- Some also suggest that if there were skull-like features on the site, it is more likely that it would have been known as “Golgotha” by both Romans and Jews.
- Another feature that makes this a likely candidate for Jesus’ tomb is its proximity to the Garden Tomb, which is considered to be one of the possible locations of Jesus’ tomb.
- One of the most compelling reasons against it is the simple fact that it hasn’t been historically recognized.
Near the Lion’s Gate
In recent years, a missionary by the name of Rodger Dusatko has proposed an alternative location near Jerusalem. This location is located on a hill just outside of the Lion’s Gate. Furthermore, the Lion’s Gate is a symbolic representation of the area where Christians see Jesus’ final journey from the jail to His crucifixion (Via Dolorosa). 330 meters northeast of where the temple formerly stood, on a steep slope beyond the wall, there is a possibility that Golgotha will be built. According to Dusatko, the word skulla is not used to describe Golgotha, which would imply that the skull is being referred to as a whole.
- This is the origin of the word “cranium,” which refers to the top, curving portion of the head.
- When assessing a suitable location for Calvary, Dusatko believes that having a straight line of sight to the temple is critical.
- And the temple’s curtain was split in two by the earthquake.
- Upon witnessing what had occurred, the centurion expressed his gratitude to God and stated, “Surely this was a virtuous man” (Luke 23:44–47).
- Some critics of the Lion’s Gate hill argue that Luke did not specifically state that the centurion witnessed the curtain being torn in half.
Luke was most likely implying that the centurion, who had watched the events of the day, had been convinced of Jesus’s righteousness.
Jesus and Adam?
One of the most intriguing traditions about the site of the crucifixion has to do with Adam’s skull, which is said to have been found nearby. Origen (A.D. 184-A.D. 253), one of the most renowned theologians and biblical experts in the early church, was the catalyst for this transformation. It was revealed to Origen in his commentary on Matthew that the corpse of Adam had been buried there in order that, “as in Adam all perish,” so too would Adam be revived and “as in Christ all would be made alive,” as well as “as in Christ all will be made alive.” Apocalyptic writer Epiphanius of Salamis (ca.
- According to Chrysostom (349–407), in his commentary on the Gospel of John, “‘And He arrived to a spot where there was a skull,'” he adds.
- The Church of the Holy Sepulchre even contains a Chapel of Adam, which is positioned beneath the alleged rock of Golgotha, as part of its complex.
- This is one of those tales that is really intriguing to learn about yet serves no benefit whatsoever.
- I think it’s pretty doubtful that we’ll ever find out where Adam’s body is buried.
So what do we know?
After all this time, it should be clear that we are unable to pinpoint the exact place of Jesus’ crucifixion. Does this imply that it never took place? In no way, shape, or form. A large number of extra-biblical narratives show that Christ was crucified in the manner described in the Gospels. Tacitus was a Roman historian (as well as a senator) who lived in the first century. It is in the Annals of the Emperor Nero that he describes how Nero responded to the fire in Rome by persecuting Christians, and it is in this that he verifies the manner in which Jesus died: As a result, in order to get rid of the report, Nero pinned the responsibility and inflicted the most exquisite tortures on a class of people despised by the crowd for their abominations and referred to as Christians.
When Christus, the man who gave his name to the religion, was executed by one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus, during the reign of Tiberius, an evil superstition that had been suppressed for a time erupted once more not only in Judaea, the origin of evil, but also in Rome, where all that is hideous and shameful from all over the world finds a home and becomes popular, was re-ignited.
- Their deaths were made much more miserable by mockery of every kind.
- Thallus was a first-century historian, and most of his work has been lost to history—but the second-century historian Sextus Julius Africanus makes use of his writings.
- Thallus, in the third book of his History, refers to this darkness as an eclipse of the sun, which looks to me to be without foundation (Julius Africanus, Chronography, 18:1).
- In putting Socrates to death, what benefit did the Athenians derive from their decision?
- What benefit did the men of Samos derive from the burning of Pythagoras’ statue?
- What benefit did the Jews derive from the assassination of their wise king?
- God avenged the three wise men in a righteous manner.
- But Socrates did not die; he continued to live on via Plato’s teachings.
- Neither did the wise monarch pass away; he continued to live via the teachings he had imparted (Mara bar Simpson, a letter to his son).
- Although we will never know where Jesus died, we may place our confidence in the assurance that:But he was pierced for our trespasses, he was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was laid on him, and it is by his wounds that we are healed (Isaiah 53:5).
- The exact site of the crucifixion is unknown, but we do know, in Paul’s words, that “we are Christ’s ambassadors, as though God were appealing to us via Christ” (2 Corinthians 5:20a).
Fortunately, Jesus’ death does not mark the end of the tale. Join us in celebrating the resurrection by reading and sharing this article. When it comes to the Resurrection of Jesus, why is it so significant?
Where was Jesus crucified?
QuestionAnswer The exact site of Jesus’ crucifixion is a source of contention among scholars today. “Golgotha,” or “the site of the skull,” is said to be the location in Matthew 27:33, Mark 15:22, Luke 23:33, and John 19:17, among other places. The Gospels provide a few further hints as to the location of the tomb. As stated in John 19:20, it was “near the city,” which suggests that it was outside the city walls, which is the most plausible interpretation. Mark 15:40 mentions that the place of Jesus’ crucifixion could be seen from a distance, which most likely suggests that it was on a high ledge or other elevated platform.
- The Church of the Holy Sepulchre and Gordon’s Calvary are the two most popularly proposed locations for the location of Jesus’ death on the cross.
- A system known as Gordon’s Calvary was initially proposed by Otto Thenius and his colleagues Fisher Howe and Claude Conder in the mid-nineteenth century, and it was popularized in the late nineteenth century by Charles Gordon.
- Major areas of the city itself have been destroyed and rebuilt several times throughout the years.
- Would the Church of the Holy Sepulchre have been built outside the city walls in the early first century?
- Is Gordon’s Calvary the result of quarrying work that took place sometime in the past 2,000 years?
- On both sides, there are strong points of view.
- There are other arguments in favor of alternative places.
- Whatever the location, there is no scriptural justification for it to be revered.
- We are no closer to God than we are in our own homes, whether we are in the tomb under the Church of the Holy Sepulchre or on the summit of Gordon’s Calvary.
Jesus was crucified, buried, and raised, according to 1 Corinthians 15:3–4 (New International Version). That is the most crucial thing. Questions regarding Jesus Christ (return to top of page) What was the location of Jesus’ crucifixion?
Golgotha – Why was Jesus crucified outside the city? — by Mark Barnes
Even if you visit the alleged location of Jesus’ crucifixion today, it’s nearly hard to picture what it must have been like thousands of years ago. To see the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, you must first enter the busy Old City of Jerusalem, and then proceed inside the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. As you weave your way among the throngs of pilgrims and the swaying arcs of Greek Orthodox oil lights, you’ll notice a white rock jutting up under an altar. Christ, according to the church, was crucified on this very spot.
- Of course, Jesus did not travel to Golgotha through the Old City.
- To the greatest extent possible, all of the gospel writers emphasize that Jesus was transported outside the city to be crucified.
- You might be asking why this is so significant.
- It is significant because Jews link sanctity and purity with certain locations.
- Leviticus 14:33-45).
A holy city and a holy God
Visit the alleged location of Jesus’ crucifixion today and it’s difficult to comprehend what it must have been like thousands of years ago. To see the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, you must first enter the crowded Old City of Jerusalem and then proceed inside the church itself. You’ll see a white rock peeping up under an altar as you weave your way among the throngs of pilgrims and swinging Greek Orthodox oil lights. Christ, according to the church, was crucified on this very site. The majority of archaeologists, maybe unexpectedly, are in agreement.
- It was time for him to go out of town.
- It is important to note that, in contrast to today, the location of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre was outside of the city walls in 30 AD.
- It is significant because Jews equate locations with sanctity and purity.
- Leviticus 14:33-45).
Outside the camp
Throughout the Bible, we may see examples of this. After they had been slaughtered, the sacrifices were carried outside the camp (Leviticus 4:12). Because the offense was so heinous, it appears as though the corpse of the animal slain as a sin offering had to be not only destroyed, but removed from the camp as well: it had to be slaughtered, burnt, and then the ashes were transported outside of it. The Exodus took place during a time when people who were ceremonially unclean were expelled from the camp (e.g.
Those who broke God’s law were also executed there (e.g., Numbers 15:32-36), a practice that continued at least until the period of the New Testament (Luke 4:29, Acts 7:58).
When you are looking away from the city, the large Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives is one of the most remarkable sites you will see. In this cemetery, located just outside of the city, up to a quarter of a million Jews are buried, with some graves going back to the time of the Old Testament.
No cleansing for the city
However, the people fail to take use of God’s gift to maintain their city clean on a consistent basis. Apocalyptic prophecy in Ezekiel 24:13 declares that the Lord ‘tried to wash you, but you would not be cleaned from your impurity,’ and as a result, “you will not be pure again until my fury against you has faded.” As a result, the people of Jerusalem are exiled, and the city itself is destroyed. Jerusalem, according to Jeremiah, has committed a tremendous sin and has become filthy as a result (Lamentations 1:8).
She and her people have been slain, burnt, and are now being transported – to the land of Babylon.
A better sacrifice
It was for this reason that Jesus, in contrast to practically all other Jews, did not regard the temple (or even Jerusalem) to be a hallowed location. It was a robber’s lair, to put it mildly. While other Jews flocked to the temple in order to get closer to God, Jesus made it a point to pray in distant locations far away from the crowds of the city. And when he felt the need to pray on the night before his crucifixion, he purposefully departed Jerusalem in order to do so, according to tradition (even today, Gethsemane is just outside the city).
- It would then be necessary to remove their bodies from the city in order to purify it of any leftover impurity.
- In truth, Jesus was the temple (John 2:19-21), he was Immanuel, God with us, and he was the Son of God.
- The actuality, on the other hand, was significantly more substantial.
- The writer to the Hebrews draws a connection between the ritual in which the carcasses of sacrificed animals are brought outside the city, especially on the day of atonement, and the ritual in which the carcasses of sacrificed animals are taken within the city.
- Likewise, Christ suffered outside the city gate in order to make the people holy via his own blood.
- Due to the fact that we do not have an enduring city here, we are looking forward to the city that is yet to be built (Hebrews 13:11–13).
- Jesus has taken the place of those Old Testament sacrifices, as evidenced by his crucifixion outside of the city walls on Good Friday.
- The fact that Jesus is the new temple means that there is no longer any redemption to be sought in the sacrifice system, but only in Jesus.
- Clinging to the things of this world may be quite seductive for us as well.
- A finer city is yet ahead of us — the ‘holy city, new Jerusalem,’ which is perfectly pure and “prepared like a bride gorgeously clothed for her husband.” We are looking forward to it (Revelation 21:2).
It is only because Jesus died outside of the city and bore our sins that we are permitted to enter that holy city.
Where was Jesus crucified?
In the Bible, the place where Jesus was crucified and died as a sacrifice for the sins of the world is referred to as Golgotha. In the King James Bible translation, this location is referred to as Calvary in the book of Luke (Luke 23:33). This allusion is made in various religious traditions to the location of Adam’s skull, which is believed to be in the Garden of Eden. Although Jesus was aware of his impending death, he did not notify his disciples of it until just before his execution (Matthew 26:2).
Many consider it to be the site of the biblical Golgotha, where Jesus and at least two other persons were crucified as criminals, as described in the Bible (Matthew 27:38, Luke 23:33).
At this area, the strong Roman Empire carried out executions, such as the one carried out on Jesus.
The connection between Jesus, a skull, and Golgotha (Calvary) may be traced back to the King James Version of the gospels. According to the book of Matthew, the Lord was carried to this area by the Romans as it states “And when they came unto a place named Golgotha, which is to say, a place of a skull, They gave him vinegar to drink mixed with gall.”. In Matthew 27:33 – 34, as well as Mark 15:22 and John 19:17, the Bible says that Early literature about this escarpment describe it as a hill that resembles a skull, which may be located near an entrance into the city of Jerusalem and is visible from afar.
However, the location of the skull seen above does not correspond to the location where Jesus was crucified according to Catholic belief.
Helena, the mother of Roman Emperor Constantine I (Constantine the Great), gave evidence in 325 that served as the basis for the document.
Constantine constructed the Church of the Holy Sepulcher around the entire spot that his mother said was the location of Jesus’ death.
It should be remembered that crucifixion is a lengthy and very painful method of executing prisoners of war. As a matter of fact, the word “excruciating,” which refers to something that is exceptionally painful or severe, derives from the Latin word for torture or suffering resulting from or caused by crucifying. Crucification was used by the Persian Empire (559–330 BCE), the Seleucid Empire (213–63 BC), the Carthaginians, the Macedonians, and the Romans, among other civilizations. Greek King Alexander the Great was executed in 332 B.C.
During the reign of Emperor Constantine, the practice of crucifixion was prohibited throughout the whole Roman Empire in 337 A.D.
He lived a blameless life for thirty-three and a half years in order to be able to give himself as the sinless, atoning sacrifice for all sins in the year 30 A.D.
Jesus and his career are marked by the enormous paradox that, by freely putting himself at the ‘place of the skull,’ or place of death, he made possible the gift of eternal life for all who trust in him. This is one of the major paradoxes of Jesus and his work.
Where is Golgotha? Where did Jesus die? Church of Holy Sepulchre vs. the Garden Tomb
Every significant event in Jesus’ life is commemorated in Israel by churches built on the locations of those events. We’ve visited the majority of them. It is believed that their current positions date back to the third century, when Christianity was authorized and churches could be constructed without fear of being demolished by the state. The Church of the Holy Sepulchre, located in Jerusalem, commemorates Jesus’ crucifixion, death, and interment (photos here). Pictured here is the location where tradition has it that Jesus was crucified.
Queen Helena sought out all the biblical places
When Queen Helena and the historian Eusebius arrived in Jerusalem in 326 with the mission of locating the site of Christ’s death and resurrection and erecting a basilica on the site, Christians in the city welcomed them and guided them to the location that is now known as the Church of the Holy Sepulchre. Non-Jewish Christians continued to live in Jerusalem after Jewish Christians were expelled from the city in 135 AD by Hadrian, the emperor of the period. This continued to provide an uninterrupted lineage back to the time of Jesus Christ.
- Christian pilgrims have venerated the location for thousands of years.
- The Church had been destroyed, but the site had miraculously survived until the Crusaders arrived in 1099 and rebuilt it from scratch.
- Even after Jerusalem was captured by the Muslims once more in 1187, a provision of the peace treaty with the Muslims stipulated that the place be kept for Christian visitors, which was duly accomplished.
- In the history of Christendom, there has never been any uncertainty.
- It wasn’t until 1870, more than 250 years after the Reformation, that a Protestant offered a different location for Christ’s death and resurrection.
The first proposal of the “Garden Tomb”
Despite the fact that the Church of the Holy Sepulchrenow stood within the city’s walls, Scottish doctor R.F. Hutchison claimed that Christ could not have died there since it went against a NewTestament verse that indicated that the crucifixion took place outside of the city. He recommended a location on the slopes of the Mount of Olives, which he believed would be ideal. It gained hold in Protestantism, but was rejected in 1884 by another Protestant, English military hero General Charles G. Gordon, who was a staunch opponent of slavery.
This Protestant alternative to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre was quickly accepted by the general public. Protestants now had their own tomb where Jesus was laid to rest. It was given the name “Garden Tomb” when it was suggested that it be the site of the crucifixion there.
What’s the problem with these new proposals for the location of Christ’s death?
digs have shown to Jewish academics, historians, and archaeologists who have no financial interest in the site of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre that the walls of Jerusalem were in a completely different location during Jesus’ time, according to recent discoveries. The existing wall that surrounds the Old City was constructed in the 16th century by the Turkish Sultan Suleiman the Magnificent, who was also known as Suleiman the Magnificent. At the time of Christ, the traditional site of Christ’s death was outside the city walls, as is customary.
- When we were in Jerusalem, we came upon a massive replica of the ancient city, which had been constructed by Jewish officials.
- This Israeli model depicts the original wall of Jerusalem, the second repaired wall, and the present 1600th century wall, which was constructed further out to accommodate the expanding city.
- Gordon’s primary motive for rejecting the Church of the Holy Sepulchre as the remains of Golgotha faded away was religious prejudice.
- This raises the question of whether or not the tomb is indeed where Jesus died.
- It is believed by many Protestants that Jesus died in the “Garden Tomb” because the cliff appeared like a skull 140 years ago, and because it was outside of the new wall (which was erected in the 16th century), which he believed to be the ancient wall, according to a non-academic.
- As an example, many evangelicals are baptized around 60 miles from the biblical baptismal location, which has a 2000-year history of being the place of the first Christian baptism.
National Graphic publishes detailed drawings of the site’s history in 2018
National Geographic, a non-denominational, secular research organization, created a series of illustrations for each step of the site’s development from the Resurrection to the modern Church of the Holy Sepulchre, beginning with the first. They make no attempt to suggest alternate places or to express any doubt about the historical significance of the site.
What’s the evidencefor thesite at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre.
- During the first century AD, the location was a disused quarry located outside the city’s perimeter walls. A series of tombs dating to the first centuries BC and AD had been excavated into the vertical west wall, which had been abandoned by the quarrymen. This church’s geographical aspects are consistent with the Gospel accounts, which state that Jesus was crucified on a rock that appeared to be a skull outside the city (John 19:17) and that there was a burial ground nearby (John19:41-2). Earth and seeds carried in by the wind and wet by winter rains would have formed the green covering on the rock that John refers to as a “garden.” According to historians Eusebius and Socrates Scholasticus, who wrote many centuries later, the Christian community of Jerusalem continued to hold worship services at the site until 66 AD. In 135 AD, the Roman Emperor Hadrian constructed a Temple of Venus on the site, which might be an indicator that the place was revered as a sacred site by Christians and other religions. Hadrian planned to establish a religious center for traditional Roman religion on the site
- Because the location chosen for the construction of Constantine’s church in 326 AD was inconvenient and expensive, the local tradition of the town would have been investigated closely when Constantine set out to build his church. It was necessary to demolish a number of significant structures, most notably the temple constructed over the site by Hadrian. The eyewitness historian Eusebius reported that the ancient memorial was unearthed during the excavations
- There has been an uninterrupted history of acknowledgement of the place since the time of Jesus’ death
The following is the conclusion reached by the Oxford Archaeological Guide to the Holy Land, based on the grounds listed above: “This appears to be the location where Jesus Christ died and was buried. Yes, it’s very likely.” According to the non-Catholic Israeli scholar Dan Bahat, who was formerly the City Archaeologist of Jerusalem, the Church of the Holy Sepulchre is the burial site of Jesus: “We may not be absolutely certain that the site of the Holy Sepulchre Church is the burial site of Jesus, but we have no other site that can lay a claim nearly as weighty, and we really have no reason to reject the authenticity of the site.”
Other Bible Topics
Tradition and Its Implications What is the deal with these “additional” books in the Bible that Catholics were not permitted to read? What is the deal with these “extra” books in the Bible? The narrative of how the Bible came to be in our possession