The Resurrected Christ appeared to 500: When and Where did this Happen?
According to Saint Paul, the risen Jesus appeared to 500 individuals. This is a fascinating detail. That’s a significant development. What is the significance of it not being mentioned in the Gospels (or is it)? We’ll go into more depth about this in this post: Throughout 1 Corinthians 15, Saint Paul recites what appears to be a formula or a creedal declaration regarding the resurrection of Jesus Christ. I’ll break it down into bullet points to make it more clear: Because I conveyed to you as a matter of first priority what I also received:
- According to Saint Paul, the risen Jesus appeared to 500 individuals. This is an intriguing detail. The significance of this is enormous. What is the significance of it not being stated in the Gospels (or is it mentioned therein?) In this post, we’ll go through the specifics: Throughout 1 Corinthians 15, Saint Paul recites what appears to be a formula or a creedal declaration regarding the resurrection of the Lord. For clarity, I’ll put it in bullet points: Rather, I presented to you first and foremost what I had also received, which was:
We have the core of the Apostles Creed (died, was buried, and rose on the third day), but we have added six more resurrection appearances to it. A total of five apparitions took place, followed by one appearance by Saint Paul himself. The apostle Paul talks of the risen Christ appearing to “more than five hundred” people, although there is no record of this event in the four Gospels or St Luke’s Acts of the Apostles to support this claim. So, what exactly is St. Paul describing?
Christ Appearing to Over 500?
There are four different perspectives on this “500 witnesses event”:
- Regarding the “500 witnesses occurrence,” there are four points of view.
There are four points of view on the “500 witnesses event”:
- Christ appeared to them inside sealed doors on the evening of Resurrection Sunday and breathed on them, and the other apostles (with the exception of Thomas) witnessed the risen Christ that same evening. Following this, the Eleven Apostles (along with Thomas) witnessed the resurrected Christ one Sunday later and allowed Thomas to place his fingers within His wounds. If the Apostles had witnessed Christ at least twice in Jerusalem, why would Christ instruct them to travel to Galilee in order to bear witness to Him there? It’s possible that this was done so that all of Christ’s disciples in Galilee might see His resurrection. This would make sense, and it is for this reason that “more than five hundred” people would witness Christ’s resurrection. This group of “more than 500” would have been the core of the 5000 who were fed and of those who had witnessed His miracles
- When Saint Paul says, “then to all the Apostles,” at the conclusion of his list, he is most likely referring to Christ’s ascension to the right hand of the Father. As a result, it is probable that the apparition to 500 occurred before the Ascension. The idea of Christ coming after the Ascension, as claimed by Saint John Chrysostom, is therefore ruled out (3). Because Christ appearing to disciples at Pentecost would have been documented by Paul’s companion Saint Luke, Chrysostom’s theory likewise eliminates the possibility of Christ appearing at Pentecost (4). We apologize for the inconvenience. After all, Saint Luke cites Christ appearing to Saint Stephen – so why would he miss an apparition of Jesus on the Feast of the Transfiguration on the Feast of the Transfiguration? As a result, it is safe to conclude that Christ did not appear on the Day of Pentecost.
Perhaps Saint Matthew reports the “500 Event” as having occurred in Galilee without specifically specifying the number “500” as well: A mountain that Jesus had designated them was where the eleven disciples proceeded on their journey into Galilee. Afterward, when they saw him, they adored him, although others were skeptical” (Mt 28:16-17). Matthew mentions just the 11 live Apostles, but he adds that “others were skeptical.” Since this occurrence occurred 13 days after the Resurrection in Jerusalem, it is safe to assume that the eleven did not have any doubts at this time.
Christ has risen from the dead!
Taylor Marshall is a medical doctor that practices in the United States.
Jesus was seen by over 500 people
1 Corinthians 15:1-11, 1 Corinthians 15:12-13, After Jesus’ resurrection, more than 500 individuals were present at the same time. Over the course of 40 days, leading up to the day Jesus returned to His Father’s house, he was seen and talked to a number of people. Jesus stated that He will return in the same manner in which He departed to Heaven. You’ll find the following 12 separate reported appearances of Jesus near the bottom of this page:
15.1Now, brothers, I’m bringing you the gospel that I preached to you, which you accepted, and on which you have made your stand,2and by which you are also being saved if you hold fast to the message I preached to you—unless, of course, your faith was completely worthless. 3Because I have forwarded to you the most crucial information that I have received: According to the Scriptures, the Messiah died for our sins,4he was buried, and he was resurrected on the third day, according to the Scriptures—and he is still alive!
6After that, he was seen by more than 500 brothers at the same time, the most majority of them are still living, while some have passed away.
9Because I persecuted God’s church, I am the least of the apostles, and I am not even qualified to be called an apostle by others.
Instead, I worked harder than everybody else—not because I was trying more, but because God’s grace was with me. 11Whether it was I or the others, this is the message we proclaim, and this is what you accepted as truth. 1 Corinthians 15:1-11 is a passage from the New Testament.
Jesus appeared in 12 separate recorded appearances: the first of twelve The appearance of Jesus to Mary Magdalene took place on either the 17th or the 21st of Nisan. Matthew 28:1, Mark 16:9-11, and John 20:11-182nd of 12 Bible verses When Jesus appeared to the other ladies, they were astonished. Matthew 28:13 is the thirteenth of twelve verses. The appearance of Jesus to two disciples (Cleophas and another) on the road to Emmaus is a significant event in the New Testament. Mark 16:12-13, Luke 24:13-32, John 24:33-35, and 1 Corinthians 15:54th of 12 are examples of passages from the Bible.
Mark 16:14, Luke 24:36-43, and 1 Corinthians 15:56th of 12 are all references to Jesus.
John 20:26 (the 317th verse of the Bible) The appearance of Jesus to seven disciples by the Sea of Galilee is a well-known event in the New Testament.
Matthew 28:16-20, Mark 16:15-189th of 12Jesus appears to approximately 500 hundred people on a mountain in Galilee, 1 Corinthians 15:610th of 12Jesus appears to James his brother, 1 Corinthians 15:7, Galatians 1:911th of 12Jesus appears to the disciples with another commission, Luke 24:44-49th of 12Jesus appears to the disciples with another commission, Luke 24:44-49th of 12Jesus appears to the disciples 12th of 12Jesus comes to the disciples with a new commission, according to Luke 24:44-49.
Acts 1:3-8 is an example of a parable.
Other modules in this unit:
New International Version (New International Version) After then, he appeared to more than five hundred of the brothers and sisters at the same time, the vast majority of them are still alive, but some have passed away, according to the records. New Living TranslationAfter that, he was seen by more than 500 of his followers at one time, the vast majority of whom are still living, while some have passed away. New Living Translation Version standardized in English Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at the same time, the vast majority of them are still living, though some have passed away due to old age or illness.
The Literal Bible of the Bereans Following that, He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at the same time, the vast majority of whom have remained to this day, albeit some have fallen asleep.
New After that, He was seen by almost five hundred brethren all at once, the vast majority of whom are still alive today, although a few have passed away.
After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at the same time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1995After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at the same time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1977After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at the same time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1995 Amplification BibleAfter then, He appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at the same time, the vast majority of whom are still living, but a few of them are no longer with us.
- The Christian Standard Bible is a translation of the Bible in the Christian tradition.
- Holman The Christian Standard Bible is a translation of the Bible in the Christian tradition.
- The American Standard Version is the version used in the United States.
- Version in the Present Tense of the English Language Immediately following this, he appeared in front of more than 500 other followers.
- The Bible of Douay-Rheims Immediately after that, he was seen by more than five hundred comrades all at once, many of whom are still alive today, while others have passed away.
The International Standard Version (ISO) is a formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized formalized In the following years, he was seen by more than 500 brothers at a single time, the vast majority of them are still living, while some have passed away.
Standard Version in its literal sense afterward He appeared to almost five hundred brethren at the same time, the majority of whom have remained till this day, and some of them have fallen asleep; New American Bible Following that, he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at the same time, the vast majority of them are still alive, while some have passed away.
His appearance to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at one point is said to have occurred; most of them are still living, but some have passed into slumber.
The New Heart English Bible is a translation of the New Heart Bible.
Weymouth The New Testament is a collection of writings that were written during the years of ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad ad Following that, He was seen by more than five hundred brethren all at the same time, the vast majority of them are still living, though some of them have passed away.
- Young’s Literal Translation of the Text Following that, he appeared to over five hundred comrades all at once, of whom the larger part have remained to this day, while a few have fallen asleep; Additional Translations.
- 5 and that He appeared first to Cephas, then to the Twelve apostles and disciples.
- 7 After that, He appeared to James, and then to the rest of the apostles.
- And it was only after he had said this that he fell asleep.
- 15:20 in 1 Corinthians 15:20 Christ, on the other hand, has certainly been resurrected from the grave, becoming the firstfruits of those who have passed away.
- His brothers number in the thousands, and he was seen by over five hundred of them all at once; the most of them are still alive, but some have passed away.
Then perish those who have fallen asleep in Christ as well as those who have not.
Acts 13:36 (KJV) For David, after having served his own age according to God’s purpose, fell asleep and was laid to rest with his fathers, where he witnessed corruption: (6)I’ve fallen asleep.
In verse 6, the author says: At the same time, there were almost five hundred brethren.
Although it is most likely that this was the appearance on the mountain, there is no way to be certain (Matthew 28:16, 17; comp.Matthew 26:32).
One of the most compelling pieces of evidence is this phrase, which is a confident contemporary plea to a large number of live witnesses made by someone who would rather die than lie.
I’d fallen asleep on the job.
As a result, the word “cemetery” means “a resting place.” Commentaries that run in parallel.
Following epi and eita, the rest of the book.
ὤφθη(ōphthē) The Aorist Indicative Form of the Verb Passive – Singular in the third person Strong’s 3708 (Strong’s 3708): In the proper sense, to gaze at something means to see clearly; as a result, to pay attention; in the Hebrew sense, to experience; passively, to appear.
Adjective – Dative Masculine Plural Five hundred people came from Pente and Hekaton.
as soon as possible (ephapax) AdverbStrong’s 2178: Once and for all; at the same time.
most (pleiones)Adjective – Nominative Masculine Most (pleiones) For example, Strong’s 4119:Or neuter pleion, or neuter pleon comparative of polus; more in quantity or quality; likewise the greater portion.of (ex) Preposition Strong’s 1537: From out, out from among, from, implying that something is coming from the inside out.
- To remain is a fundamental verb.
- ConjunctionStrong’s 1161:A primary particle; however, and, and so on.
- I’ve fallen asleep on the job.
- to sleep; metaphorically, to die Go back to the previous page After that, alive, appeared, and fell asleep.
OncePartPresentLinks 1 Corinthians 15:6 (New International Version) 1 Corinthians 15:6 (New Living Translation) 1 Corinthians 15:6 (New International Version) 1 Corinthians 15:6 (New American Standard Bible) 1 Corinthians 15:6 King James Version 1 Corinthians 15:6BibleApps.com – 1 Corinthians 15:6 1 Corinthians 15:6 Biblia Paralela (Parallel Bible) Chinese translation of 1 Corinthians 15:6 French translation of 1 Corinthians 15:6.
The verse 1 Corinthians 15:6 says, Letters from the Catholic Bible to the New Testament: The verse 1 Corinthians 15:6 says, Then he appeared to more than five hundred people (1 Cor. 1C iC) in one appearance. 1Cor I cor icor) 1Cor I cor icor)
Post-Resurrection Appearances of Jesus: The Five Hundred Believers — Hope On Demand
a new International Version has been published In the following days, he appeared to more than five hundred of the brothers and sisters at the same time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though a few have died. His followers swarmed around him, and he was seen by more than 500 of them at one time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though some have passed away. the standard version of the english language Afterwards, he appeared to more than five hundred brothers all at once, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though a few have passed away in their sleep.
Immediately following that, He appeared to more than five hundred brothers at the same time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though some have passed away.
The King James Bible (also known as the King James Version) is a book written by the English author James I.
New Afterwards, He was seen by more than five hundred brethren all at once, the vast majority of whom have survived to the present day, but a few have passed away.
Bible) After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at one time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1995After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1977After that, He appeared to more than five hundred brethren at one time, the majority of whom have survived to the present, but some have passed away;NASB 1995After that, In the following years, He appeared to more than five hundred of His brothers and sisters at a time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though some have passed away.
New International Version of the Bible (also known as the Christian Standard Version) Then he appeared to over five hundred brothers and sisters at the same time; the majority of them are still alive, but some have passed away due to old age or illness.
Standard Version (also known as the American Standard Version): In the next instant, he appeared to over 500 brothers and sisters in a single instant.
Simple Translation of the Aramaic Bible In the following days, he appeared to a group of more than 500 brethren, many of whom have remained until this day, while others have passed away.’ Version in the Present Day (Current English) His appearance to more than 500 other followers followed shortly after.
The Bible from Douay-Rheims More than five hundred of his brethren were present at the same time, many of whom are still alive today, while others have died.
ANSI/ISBE/ISO/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/IEC/I The following year, he was seen by more than 500 brothers all at the same time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though some have passed away.
BIBLE ON NETWORKED EXCHANGE His appearance to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at one time is believed to have occurred; most of them are still alive, though some have died.
Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers and sisters at the same time, the vast majority of whom are still alive, though some have passed away, according to tradition.
Weymouth Revelations of Jesus Christ (New Testament) Revelation of Jesus Christ (New Testament) Revelation of Jesus Christ (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) (New Testament) ( Later, He was seen by over 500 brethren all at the same time, the vast majority of them are still living, but some have passed away recently.
- The Bible in English as a second language across the world His appearance to almost five hundred brothers happened all at once, and most of them have survived to this day, while some have passed away.
- 5) and that He manifested Himself to Cephas and later to the Twelve apostles.
- 7 James was the first of the apostles who saw Him, and subsequently everyone else.
- Following this, he promptly fell asleep on the couch.
- 1 Corinthians 15:20 is a biblical passage that states Although Jesus was risen from the dead, he is still considered the firstfruits of those who have passed away.
- The Bible says in Matthew 28:10,16, and 17 “Do not be frightened; go tell my brethren that they are going towards Galilee, and there they will see me,” Jesus instructed them.
Verse 60 of the book of Acts Lord, do not hold this transgression against them, he said, kneeling down and crying out with a loud voice.
Acts 13:36 is a biblical passage.
6 – I’ve fallen asleep.
In verse 6, the author says, ” All at once there were more than 500 brothers and sisters present.
In any case, it is very likely that this is what happened when the creature appeared on the mountain (Matthew 28:16, 17; comp.Matthew 26:32).
One who would rather die than lie makes a confident contemporaneous appeal to a large number of live witnesses in this line, which has the highest evidence value possible.
I’ve dozed off.
“A sleeping area,” as the name “cemetery” suggests.
Then he showed up ὤφθη(ōphthē) Aorist Indicative Verb – Aorist Passive Person Singular in the Third Person Strength 3708 (Strong’s 3708) is defined as To properly gaze at something, i.e.
V(epan) is an abbreviation for more than AdverbStrong’s 1883: “From epi and ano; up above, i.e., above or on.
A total of five hundred people came from pente and hekaton.
without further ado (ephapax) One time, once and for all; all at once, according to AdverbStrong’s 2178 On one case, it was derived from epi and hapax; The most (pleiones)Adjective – Nominative Masculine Most (pleiones) For example, Strong’s 4119:Or neuter pleion, or neuter pleon comparative of polus; more in quantity or quality; likewise the greater portion.of (ex) Preposition According to Strong’s 1537: “from the outside in,” “from among,” “from among themselves,” “from among themselves” Origin, from, and out are all denoted by the preposition whomὧν(hōn) Personal / Relative Pronoun – Masculine Genitive Form What is the meaning of PluralStrong’s 3739: who is still living, which is still alive, what is still alive?
- μένουσιν(menousin) The present indicative active form of the verb is: The third person is used to refer to someone.
- To remain is a fundamental verb.
- ConjunctionStrong’s 1161: A primary particle; however, and, and so on.
- am am dozing off (ekoimthsan)Verb – Aorist Indicative Passive Aorist Strong’s 2837:From keimai, which means to put to sleep, i.e.
- Go back to the previous page After that, alive, appeared, and was sleeping.
OncePartPresentLinks In the New International Version, 1 Corinthians 15:6 says 15:6 New International Version Ephesians 15:6 ESV (English Standard Version) 15:6 (New American Standard Bible) In 1 Corinthians 15:6, the King James Version (KJV) states that BibleApps.com has the verse 1 Corinthians 15:6.
Chinese version of 1 Corinthians 15:6 French translation of 1 Corinthians 15:6 Corinthians chapter 15 verse 6 NT Letters from the Catholic Bible: Corinthians chapter 15 verse 6 When Jesus appeared to over 500 people (1 Cor. 1C iC), it was a revelation. cori coricor) 1Cori coricor) Cori coricor
What’s up with those 500 witnesses?
I appreciate that my church family is full of Bible students who are eager to pour over the text of Scripture, not wanting to miss anything that God is saying and wanting to understand what he is saying. This is one of the things I appreciate about my church family. As a result, I receive a lot of interesting questions from our members. Recently, I was asked about the 500 people who claimed to have seen the risen Christ. What particular evidence do they offer in support of the resurrection? The statement made by the apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians 15 is the subject of the question.
- Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at the same time, the vast majority of them are still living, though some have passed away due to old age or illness.
- Last but not least, he appeared to me as if he were an untimely born child.
- So let us take a look at these witnesses.
- We know they were Christians because he refers to them as “brothers” in his letter.
- 1 Corinthians was most likely written by Paul in the early to mid-fifties AD.
- It appears that Paul provides us with a rough chronology of the resurrection appearances, beginning with the appearances to Peter and the disciples and concluding with the appearances to Paul and the other apostles.
- As a result, this event would have occurred prior to Paul’s Damascus Road encounter.
- As a result, this event would have occurred approximately 20 years before Paul wrote the book of 1 Corinthians.
- In the event that Paul was simply fabricating a story, he would have been a fool to put that number out there, especially one of such magnitude.
For more information, see John Piper’s explanation: “What makes this so relevant is that it was written to Greeks who were skeptical of such claims at the time many of these witnesses were still alive.” In that case, it was a risky claim if it could be disproved through some firsthand investigation.” Paul, on the other hand, isn’t concerned about it because he knows he’s telling the truth.
- When it comes to understanding why people saw Jesus, the hallucination theory has been advanced before.
- People no longer “share” hallucinations in the same way that they used to “share” dreams.
- Once again, the sheer number of people that Paul throws into the mix is astounding.
- The most logical explanation for why Paul would do something like that is simply that he is documenting what actually happened in the first place.
- This isn’t a fabrication in the least.
- “There are literally hundreds of people who can vouch for my credibility,” says the witness.
- We don’t have any further information on them outside the one reference made by Paul.
Back then, the significance of these 500 witnesses lay in the fact that they formed part of Paul’s compelling argument for the significance of the historicity of the resurrection.
It is important that it be genuine and literal, and that it is grounded in reality!
He’s lecturing about a very particular subject.
Suddenly, a heart that had remained motionless for the whole weekend began to beat once more.
It was the Judean air that caused the lungs to begin to function.
The physical senses of other people, a total of over 500 people, were used to perceive the flesh and bone body with Galilean traits that had been created.
Those who believe in the significance of the resurrection narrative believe it is due to the fact that Jesus, though still dead, continues to live on in our hearts and minds.
The following was posted on a website dedicated to “Progressive Christianity,” and it caught my attention.
It might be seen in a strictly mythological light to communicate a lesson, or in a metaphorical light of the rebirth we all experience when we give of ourselves for others.
If, on the other hand, the physical resurrection of Christ did not take place, what is the point of Paul recounting a succession of witnesses who really saw the resurrected Lord in the first place?
Although Paul stresses witnesses, this is because he is attempting to convince us that whether or not the resurrection is literal does in fact make a difference in our lives.
Given that Christ has been declared to have been resurrected from the dead, how can some of you assert that there is no such thing as a resurrection of the dead?
And if Christ has not been resurrected from the dead, then our teaching has been in vain, as has been your faith.
(See 1 Corinthians 15:12-15 for more.) However, things grow worse.
if that is the point, then we are all doomed to eternal damnation.
If our only hope in Christ is for this life, we are the most pitiable of all the people on the face of the earth.
The game is done.
In fact, if Christ is still in the tomb, it indicates that He is a sinner just like the rest of us, for death, as the payment of sin, is what we all deserve.
Because if there is no payment for sin, then we will all pay the price in Hell for our actions.
It will determine whether or not you will be pardoned.
In reality, Christ has been resurrected from the grave, and he is the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep in Christ.
In the same way that everyone dies in Adam, everyone will be brought alive in Christ.
It is at this point that Jesus restores the kingdom to God the Father, having destroyed every rule, authority, and power that had been established before.
Death is the very last adversary to be defeated.
All things will be brought under his control when all things are brought under his control, and the Son himself will be subjugated to him who brought all things under his control, so that God may be all in all.
There is a great deal at stake in determining whether or not those 500 witnesses, Paul, and the disciples are correct.
A New Creation, a restored world, an overthrow of demonic, AntiChrist rulers and authorities and forces, as well as a Cosmos that is in submission to Him are all part of the picture.
We should be grateful to God for the more than 500 witnesses.
While the people of Paul’s day had the opportunity to question the 500 eyewitnesses for proof of the resurrection’s actuality, we do not have access to their precise testimony at this time.
We now have the words of Jesus himself in our possession.
He was spot on when it came to predicting what would happen to Him.
He foresaw that all of His disciples would turn their backs on Him.
He predicted that the tomb would be unoccupied three days after he made his prediction.
Things did happen as he predicted, and they did happen.
“.you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming on the clouds of heaven.” If He has shown to be so dependable so far, how silly we would be to ignore what He says about what is to come.
As time progresses, all of humanity will come before this Man in reverence, and genuine knees will be bowed, and genuine tongues will declare that Jesus Christ is truly Lord, to the glory of God the Father.
Thank God that the tomb has been found empty and that Jesus has not remained dead! Grace and peace to you, Pastor Demer is a man of God.
To Whom Did Jesus Appear after His Death?
They were the primary reason the disciples believed in the resurrection of Jesus because they witnessed Him alive after He had been declared dead. Jesus appeared to His disciples in a living state on a number of occasions throughout His ministry. It is as a result of this that we see them testifying time and time again to the fact that they were eyewitnesses to His resurrection. Because the disciples had direct knowledge of the resurrection, they provide a significant argument in favor of the resurrection of Christ.
- The Testimony of Jesus Regarding His Resurrection Jesus’ own personal witness of His resurrection from the dead is the first piece of evidence.
- And I am in possession of the keys of death and Hades (Revelation 1:18).
- Take a look at my fingers and toes.
- You can feel my flesh and bones, and you will realize that a ghost does not have flesh and bones, as you can see I do (Luke 24:39).
- The following were the people who made an appearance.
- Mary Magdalene was the first person to see Jesus after he ascended into heaven.
- ‘Woman, what is the cause of your tears?’ Jesus inquired.
She turned to face him and said, ‘Rabboni!’ (which translates as ‘Teacher’) (John 20:14-16).
Mary the Mother of James, Salome, and Joanna are three of the most important women in the Bible.
This occurred following the apparition of Jesus to Mary Magdalene.
And lo and behold, Jesus came up to them and welcomed them.
Once again, we are treated to an unexpected appearance.
Peter When Paul mentions witnesses, Peter is the first to come to mind, and he is also the first of the apostles to view the resurrected Christ.
The gospels are utterly deafeningly quiet about the specifics of this gathering.
On the Road to Emmaus, There Were Two Disciples Later on Easter Sunday, Jesus appeared to two disciples on the road to Emmaus, according to the Gospel of Luke.
And they were having a conversation with one another about all that had happened.
However, they were unable to recognize him because of their eyesight (Luke 24:13-16).
It was in reality because they had lost faith in Him that they were departing from Jerusalem.
This is the final of Jesus’ five appearances on Easter Sunday, and it is the most dramatic.
It is reported in both Luke’s and John’s gospels, providing us with two completely separate versions of what occurred in that day.
Following his statement, he demonstrated his hands and his side to the group of onlookers.
However, Thomas, one of the twelve disciples, known as Didymus, was not there when Jesus appeared (John 20:19, 20, 24).
It was eight days later when He reappeared, this time with Thomas in attendance.
Jesus entered through the closed doors and stood in the center of the crowd, saying, “Peace to you!” “Reach your finger here and look at my hands,” he instructed Thomas.
‘Do not be unbelievers, but rather believers.” After that, Thomas responded by exclaiming to him, ‘My Lord and My God!
Another appearance took place on the Sea of Galilee, where Jesus appeared to seven disciples.
Simon Peter, Thomas named Didymus, Nathanael of Cana in Galilee, and the sons of Zebedee, as well as two other disciples, were all present at the same time (John 21:1, 2).
Additionally, the story of Jesus coming before His eleven disciples in Galilee is told in the Bible.
And when they saw him, they worshipped him; nevertheless, some were hesitant to do so (Matthew 28:16, 17).
On another instance, Jesus appeared to over 500 individuals at the same time on a single date.
James In addition, the Bible claims that Jesus appeared to His half-brother James.
The specifics of this apparition have not been documented.
And as he went, he drew close to Damascus, at which point a halo of light flashed around him from above.
In response, the Lord responded, “I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting” (Acts 9:3-5).
They were successful in convincing His disciples that He had resurrected from the grave.
Furthermore, Jesus demonstrated to them that he was alive after his suffering via several persuasive demonstrations, coming to them over a period of forty days and spoke of matters pertaining to the kingdom of God (Acts 1:3) SummaryAccording to the Bible, Jesus made a number of public appearances following His death.
In the Bible, it is expressly stated that on Easter Sunday, Jesus appeared to Mary Magdalene, the ladies who came to Jesus’ tomb (Mary the Mother of James, Salome, and Joanna), Peter, and two disciples who were traveling on the Emmaus road.
Later, he appeared in front of them with Thomas in attendance.
During another appearance, he was in front of more than five hundred individuals at the same time.
The character James makes an appearance as well. At long last, Jesus appeared to Saul of Tarsus, the man who would go on to become known as the Apostle Paul. Any of these appearances convinced His disciples that He had risen from the grave beyond all reasonable doubts.
Did Matthew Record Jesus’ Resurrection Appearance to 500?
They were the primary reason the disciples believed in the resurrection of Jesus because they saw Him alive after He had been declared dead. A number of times during His ministry, Jesus appeared to His disciples as a living person. Consequently, we see them testifying to the fact that they were eyewitnesses to His resurrection on a consistent basis. Because the disciples have firsthand knowledge of the resurrection, they are a compelling argument in favor of the resurrection. It was because they saw Him with their own eyes that the disciples were convinced He had risen.
- Greetings, I am the Living One; I was dead, but lo and behold, I am alive for all time!
- When Jesus says anything, it is recorded by Luke.
- The answer is yes, it is I.
- A Look at Jesus’ Various Appearances Following Jesus’ resurrection, a large number of individuals claimed to have seen him.
- A woman named Mary Magdalene had the privilege of seeing Jesus’ first appearance.
- ‘Woman, why are you crying?’ Jesus inquired of her.
- ‘Sir, if you have brought him away, please tell me where you have laid him, and I will come and take him away,’ she replied, taking him for the gardener.
She turned to face him and said, “Rabboni!” (which translates as “Teacher”).
This was a completely unexpected presence.
The incident occurred following Mary Magdalene’s presence in the garden.
They were surprised to find Jesus there to meet them and say hello.
Once again, we are greeted by an unexpected guest.
Peter When Paul mentions witnesses, Peter is the first to come to mind, and he is also the first apostle to see the resurrected Christ.
What transpired during this encounter is largely unexplained in the gospels.
On the Emmaus Road, there were two disciples.
And lo and behold, two of them were on their way to a place named Emmaus, which was approximately seven miles away from Jerusalem, that very same morning.
Then, as they were speaking and debating, Jesus himself approached them and agreed to accompany them on their journeys.
This pair of disciples, like the ladies, had no expectation of Jesus’ resurrection.
There are no Disciples in the presence of Thomas During Easter Sunday’s five-day period, Jesus makes his final public appearance.
As a result, we have two different versions of what transpired, one from Luke’s gospel and one from John’s gospel.
Following his statement, he demonstrated his hands and his side to the group of onlookers Therefore, when the disciples finally saw the Lord, they were overjoyed.
The entire group of disciples He reappeared eight days later, this time with Thomas in attendance.
Jesus entered through the closed doors and stood in the center of the crowd, saying, “Peace be with you!”.
“Reach your hand here and push it into my side,” he instructed.
Jesus said this in John 20:26–28.
On the Sea of Galilee, Jesus made a second appearance to seven disciples.
Simon Peter, Thomas named Didymus, Nathanael of Cana in Galilee, and the sons of Zebedee, as well as two other disciples, were all there at this time (John 21:1, 2).
Additionally, the story of Jesus coming before His eleven disciples in Galilee is told in the New Testament.
And when they saw him, they worshipped him; nonetheless, some were skeptics about his abilities (Matthew 28:16, 17).
An other event occurred in which Jesus appeared to a group of approximately 500 individuals at the same time.
James Jesus appeared to His half-brother James, according to the Scriptures.
A record of this appearance does not contain any specifics.
After traveling for some time across Syria, he arrived close to the city of Damascus, at which point an angelic light shined around him from above.
The appearances of Jesus that are recorded in the New Testament are the following: The deception succeeded in persuading His disciples that He had been raised from the grave.
Aside from that, by numerous persuasive proofs he shown himself alive after his suffering, coming to them over a period of forty days and talked about the subjects pertaining to God’s Kingdom (Acts 1:3) Brief SynopsisAccording to the Bible, Jesus appeared in a variety of places after His death.
In the Bible, it is expressly stated that on Easter Sunday, Jesus appeared to Mary Magdalene, the ladies who came to Jesus’ tomb (Mary the Mother of James, Salome, and Joanna), Peter, and two disciples who were traveling on the Emmaus Road.
Thomas was present when Christ later appeared to them.
When he appeared in front of over 500 people at the same time, it was a record.
In addition, James makes an appearance. Last but not least, Jesus himself appeared to Saul of Tarsus, the man who would go on to be known as the Apostle Paul. All of His appearances convinced His disciples that He had risen from the grave beyond any reasonable doubts.
What happened to the 500 witnesses in 1 Corinthians 15?
In addition to the apostles, there is at least one more account that claims a group larger than the apostles saw Jesus following his resurrection. Luke 24:33-37 (ESV translation): They arose at the same time the next morning and returned to Jerusalem. After that, they discovered the eleven and others who were with them, who were gathered together and exclaimed, “The Lord has certainly risen, and has appeared to Simon!” Afterwards, they related what had transpired on the journey and how he had been familiar to them during the breaking of the bread.
The size of the group, on the other hand, is not specified.
I believe the earliest estimate of the number of disciples comes from the book of Acts, which states that there were 120 disciples at the time of Judas’ replacement, which occurred shortly after Jesus’ ascension: Then, in those days, Peter stood up in the midst of the disciples (the total number of names was approximately one hundred and twenty) (Acts 1:15, NKJV quoted – some versions use the words ‘brethren’ or ‘brothers’ instead of ‘disciples’ with the same meaning)This is a counter-argument to the claim that 500 people saw Jesus – one would not expect the number of followers to decrease after such a miraculous appearance.
If we consider the events in Luke 24 and John 20 to be representative of the episode that Paul is referring to, we have two probable outcomes:
- It is possible that this was a different assembly—a “scene shift” is suggested by the introduction “in those days”—and hence it is not required that all of the people be there for the gathering. The figure of 120 may refer to males alone, but the figure of 500+ may refer to women and children as well as men. We know from biblical accounts that women and children were not counted in the feeding of the 5000, so this type of conduct is not unprecedented.
Where is what they wrote?
As for the location of their writings (which I assume is the most important element of your query), I believe that Scripture alone will not be able to provide an answer. Of course, it’s important to remember that not everyone understood how to write (or how to write effectively), and even if they did, it’s possible that their writing was lost or destroyed during the time period in question (for various reasons). And it’s unlikely that many people would have needed to write. It’s possible that telling everyone they knew in person would have been more convenient for them.
Despite the fact that they may have witnessed and believed, family obligations, poverty, or a bad reputation-and we know that many of Jesus’ followers were poor or of a sinful reputation-could have kept them from the business of spreading the gospel, and as a result, they might not have had a compelling reason to do so.
Christians were accused of blasphemy (e.g., Acts 6:8-14), admonished by Jewish officials not to speak (e.g., Acts 5:27-28), beaten (e.g., Acts 5:40), imprisoned (e.g., Acts 8:1-3), and even put to death (e.g., Acts 6:8-14) for their beliefs (e.g.Acts 7:54-60).
Many would have been hushed if they had really been subjected to persecution; the threat of being subjected to it would very certainly have muted much more.
What Skeptical Scholars Admit about the Resurrection Appearances of Jesus
On June 26, 2000, the television network ABC broadcasted a documentary titled The Search for Jesus. Peter Jennings, the network’s most prominent news anchor, conducted interviews with liberal and conservative experts of early Christianity to learn more about what we may learn about Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection from historical records. The series came to a close with a powerful speech from New Testament scholar Paula Fredriksen, who is not herself a Christian. In response to questions about Jesus’ post-Resurrection appearances, Fredriksen stated, “I know that what they saw was the risen Jesus in their own words.” That’s what they claim, and then all of the historical information we have afterwards confirms their belief that this is exactly what they witnessed.
- I was not present.
- But, as a historian, I’m confident that they must have witnessed something significant.
- Fredriksen is not the only one who believes that these followers must have witnessed something unusual.
- This is what sparked the birth of the world’s most populous religion.
- Two thousand years later, the message of Jesus’ death and resurrection is being preached by billions of Christians in almost every country and in nearly every language spoken on the face of the planet Earth.
A Bedrock Confession
Following the death and resurrection of Jesus, according to the earliest source we have for the event, a hidden pearl contained inside 1 Corinthians 15, Jesus appeared to a number of individuals and organizations, as well as at least one adversary. According to practically all experts, this creedal tradition goes back to a period of five years after Jesus’ death on the cross. We can trace our lineage back to the early years of the Christian movement in Jerusalem, to the foundational confession of the very first disciples of Jesus, thanks to the use of this source.
- After then, he appeared to more than five hundred of the brothers and sisters at the same time, the vast majority of them are still alive, but some have passed away, according to the records.
- There is no other inventory of Resurrection appearances like this anywhere else in the New Testament, or even in all of ancient literature, to compare.
- As well as this, we discover that Jesus appeared to three groups of people: the Twelve (excluding Judas), more than 500 early followers, and the entire assembly of apostles.
- When Paul indicates that the majority of them are still alive, he takes a risk with his reputation and puts it on the line.
- The fact that reliable eyewitness testimony to the risen Jesus was easily accessible in the decades following his resurrection might be seen as evidence of this.
- Mary Magdalene also fits on the list of important eyewitnesses because she, like the other eyewitnesses, was easily accessible to be questioned about her encounter with the resurrected Jesus after his resurrection.
Ehrman in his book How Jesus Became God, that Mary Magdalene “enjoys such prominence in all of the Gospel Resurrection accounts, despite the fact that she is almost missing anywhere else in the Gospels.” In the whole New Testament, she is mentioned just once in connection with Jesus during his public ministry (Luke 8:1–3), yet despite this, she is always the first to report that Jesus has been risen from the dead.
What is the reason behind this?
It was bestowed to Mary Magdalene the distinction of being not only the first person in history to view the resurrected Jesus, but also the first person in history to announce, “I have seen the Lord!” (See also John 20:18.) Whatever it was that these eyewitnesses witnessed changed their lives to the point that they were prepared to suffer and die as a result.
On his excursions around the Roman Empire, he was beaten, imprisoned, stoned, hungry, and lost at sea, and he was always in risk of being attacked by every kind of evil.
For example, Peter was nailed on a cross. James had been stoned. Paul was executed by beheading. Whatever it was that they witnessed was worth risking their lives for. They sealed their testimony with the blood of their victims.
The Magic Wand of ‘Mass Hysteria’
Some scholars have speculated that the eyewitnesses to the Resurrection were simply hallucinating in order to explain away these appearances of the Resurrection. Dale Allison, a New Testament scholar, has written an excellent book, Resurrecting Jesus, in which he surveys the scientific studies and literature on hallucinations that have been published. He finds that in documented occurrences, there are four things that do not occur, as follows: (or rarely happen). For starters, hallucinations are seldom witnessed by many individuals or groups over a prolonged period of time, according to research.
Third, no evidence has ever been shown to support the claim that a deceased person has been revived.
(It’s also worth noting that hallucinations are not typically associated with the founding of global movements or the establishment of world religions.) Nonetheless, in the case of Jesus’ resurrection appearances, every single one of these extremely rare or seemingly impossible circumstances has come to pass in the same instance.
Even if one person has a hallucination, twelve people at the same time?
“These are legitimate questions, and waving the magical wand of’mass hysteria’ will not make them go away.” “Mass hysteria is not a panacea for all problems.”
In the face of such a compelling historical record, the only alternative option offered by credible experts is some form of “I don’t know.” “That Jesus’ followers (and later Paul) had Resurrection experiences is, in my opinion, a fact,” argues noted New Testament scholar E. P. Sanders in The Historical Figure of Jesus. “That Jesus’ followers (and later Paul) had Resurrection experiences is, in my opinion, a fact.” “I have no idea what the reality was that gave rise to the experiences.” Jordan Peterson, a well-known professor of psychology at the University of Toronto, is also included in this group of individuals.
Upon being questioned explicitly if Jesus had truly arose from the grave, Peterson said, “I’d need to think about it for approximately three more years before I’d even attempt a response beyond what I’ve already said.” The cautious-point agnostic’s of view is one that ought to be heard.
Nonetheless, if someone with an open mind and heart, such as Peterson, pursues the evidence wherever it goes, I am confident that he will find himself at Jesus’ feet, saying with Thomas, “My Lord and my God!” (See also John 20:28.)
The remarkable character of Jesus’ resurrection reminds me of a moment from Shakespeare’sHamlet, which is one of my favorite scenes in all of literature. The play starts with the “wondrous weird” apparition of Hamlet’s deceased father to Bernardo and Marcellus, and then to Hamlet’s friend Horatio, which are described as “wondrous odd” in nature. As the skeptic of the group, Horatio is challenged by Hamlet to reconsider his skepticism about supernatural events in the following exchange: But this is amazing weird!
- In any case, as a stranger, please accept my greetings.
- When Shakespeare communicates via Hamlet, he is advising us to be prepared for the unthinkable.
- It is, without a doubt, marvelous and weird that the ghost of Hamlet’s father is coming to people, but do not dismiss it just on the basis of this fact.
- Everything in our magnificent planet (and beyond) is happening at a faster rate than you can possibly fathom.
- The ancient world, as well as present times, should be viewed with an open mind when miraculous claims are made.
The most crucial question to ask about any miracle claim is, “What proof do you have to back up your claim?” After all, even from the most critical researchers’ perspective, we have seen that the weight of the historical evidence attests that a large number of persons and groups thought they had seen the rising Jesus.
What makes you think they’re lying?
Moreover, we may go beyond the first century to discover how believing in the Resurrection lay the groundwork for all of Western civilization, inspiring some of the world’s greatest works of art and literature as well as works of music, film, philosophy, morals, and ethics.
And if all of that isn’t enough, let our Horatios look around at the billions of people all across the globe who are willing to attest to how the living Christ has altered their lives right before their eyes.
They have discovered in Christ all of the treasures of wisdom and understanding that can be found.
They are looking for it in you.
Before Easter goes away into the shuffle of regular life, ask your neighbor: What (or who) did all those witnesses witness and how did they perceive it?
This is indeed a wondrous strangeness!
Justin Bass is a professor of New Testament at Jordan Evangelical Theological Seminary in Amman, Jordan, where he lives with his wife and children.
[This article is also accessible in the following languages: Espanol and Portuguese.]