Why Did Pontius Pilate Have Jesus Executed?
“What is truth?” Pontius Pilate asks Jesus of Nazareth in the Gospel of John, and Jesus responds with a question. It’s a question that may be raised regarding Pilate’s own personal background as well. According to the New Testament of the Christian Bible, the Roman ruler of Judea was a shaky judge who originally exonerated Jesus before bowing to the will of the multitude and condemned him to death as a result of his actions. Non-Biblical sources, on the other hand, present him as a barbaric commander who wilfully rejected the traditions of the Jewish people under his command.
WATCH: JESUS: A HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE VaultJesus before Pilate, just before he was crucified.
Pilate’s early life is a mystery.
Before his time as Roman governor of Judea, from 26 and 36 A.D., nothing is known about Pilate’s early life and career. While most believe he was born into an equestrian family in Italy, certain tales indicate that he was actually born in the Scottish Highlands. From the Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria emerges one of the earliest—and most damning—accounts of Pilate’s reign as governor. Around the year 50 A.D., he denounced the prefect for “briberies, insults, robberies, outrages and wanton injuries, executions without trial, constantly repeated, endless and extremely severe brutality,” among other things.
- Patterson describes Pilate’s rule as “corrupt and full of bribery.” Patterson is an early Christianity historian at Willamette University and the author of several books, including The Forgotten Creed: Christianity’s Original Struggle Against Bigotry, Slavery, and Sexism.
- “Philo is a really dramatic writer,” she observes, “and one who has very apparent biases: persons who maintain Jewish rules are documented in highly favorable ways, whereas people who do not uphold Jewish laws are represented in quite bad ways.
- MORE INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND AT: The Bible asserts that Jesus was a real person.
- Prior to his crucifixion, Jesus had been tortured, and this was the culmination of that suffering.
Pilate clashed with the Jewish population in Jerusalem.
A pair of golden shields emblazoned with the name of the Roman Emperor Tiberius were allowed into King Herod’s ancient residence in Jerusalem, according to Philo, despite Jewish tradition. Writing more than a half-century later, the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus related a similar story, claiming that Pilate let troops bearing military standards with the likeness of the emperor into Jerusalem, despite Jewish law prohibiting the carrying of images in the holy city. A large number of people journeyed to the Judean city of Caesarea to express their displeasure, and they laid prostrate outside Pilate’s palace for five days until he finally yielded.
This account has the ring of a rookie governor experimenting with his powers and entirely underestimating the depth of local opposition to graven images.
Josephus related another event, this one with a bloodier conclusion, in which Pilate used cash from the Temple treasury to construct an aqueduct to provide water to Jerusalem.
They were successful. When he gave the signal, they withdrew clubs disguised in their clothing and beat many of the demonstrators to death with the clubs they had removed. More information may be found at: Where Is the Head of Saint John the Baptist?
The Gospels portray an indecisive Pilate.
Josephus also referred to Pilate’s well-known role in agreeing to Jesus’ death, which he had played previously. After being gravely concerned by his teachings, the Sanhedrin (an elite council of priestly and lay elders) arrested Jesus while he was celebrating the Jewish festival of Passover, according to the Gospels. They hauled Jesus before Pilate to be prosecuted for blasphemy, accusing him of claiming to be the King of the Jews, which they said was false. And they exerted pressure on Pilate, the only person who had the authority to sentence someone to death, to order his crucifixion.
According to the Gospel of Mark, Pilate intervened on Jesus’ behalf before caving in to the demands of the mob.
MORE INFORMATION CAN BE FOUND AT: Discovering the Early Christian Church’s Conversion Tactics from Within “Mark’s goal isn’t truly historical in nature,” Patterson explains.
Mark blamed the Jewish rulers in Jerusalem for the city’s collapse since the high priests and officials had turned their backs on Jesus when he had arrived in the city.
courtesy of DeAgostini/Getty Images Following this, according to the Gospel of Matthew, Pilate washed his hands in front of the assembled throng before declaring, “I am innocent of this man’s blood; take care of yourself.” When the Jewish people heard this, they yelled out, “His blood be on us and our children.” For millennia, it would be used to punish the Jewish people, and it is still being utilized now.
As Bond explains, “Matthew claims that, while Romans were accountable for carrying out the action, the Jews were liable—a line of thought that, of course, has had fatal ramifications ever since.” When Jesus was making problems during a gathering like Passover, when the city was packed to capacity, I don’t believe Pilate would have spent much time worrying about what to do with him.
According to the Gospels, the people preferred the criminal Barabbas than Jesus.
The so-called custom of freeing a prisoner on Passover has been investigated by scholars, but so far, according to Patterson, “they have not discovered anything in regard to this so-called ritual.” More information may be found at: Early Christians Didn’t Always Take the Bible Literally (Discovery).
Pilate disappears from history after his rule.
Following the use of disproportionate force to quell a suspected Samaritan rebellion, Pilate was dismissed from office and transported back to Rome, according to Josephus and the Roman historian Tacitus. Pilate vanished from the historical record as soon as he arrived in Rome. According to various legends, he was either executed by Emperor Caligula or committed suicide, with his remains being thrown into the Tiber River after his death. It has also been claimed by early Christian theologian Tertullian that Pilate became a follower of Jesus and attempted to convert the emperor to Christianity.
A portion of a carved stone with Pilate’s name and title etched in Latin on it was discovered face down in an antique theater, where it had been used as a stair.
According to a November 2018 article in Israel Exploration Journal, improved photography showed Pilate’s name engraved in Greek on a 2,000-year-old copper alloy ring recovered at Herodium, which was previously thought to be a Roman coin.
Bible Study: Who Actually Killed Jesus Christ?
On January 9, 2019, we made some changes. The killing of Christina was orchestrated by six co-conspirators, each of them contributed to the process in their own way. Their motivations ranged from avarice to hatred to a sense of obligation. Judas Iscariot, Caiaphas, the Sanhedrin, Pontius Pilate, Herod Antipas, and an unknown Roman centurion were among those who were arrested. The Old Testament prophets had predicted that the Messiah would be taken to the slaughterhouse like a sacrificial lamb hundreds of years before.
Discover the role that each of the men who executed Jesus played in the most significant trial in history, as well as how they conspired to put him to death in the most important trial in history.
Judas Iscariot – Betrayer of Jesus Christ
James Tissot’s painting Judas betraying Jesus with a kiss is available for purchase. Images courtesy of SuperStock / Getty Images Judas Iscariot was one of Jesus Christ’s twelve chosen disciples, and he was betrayed by them. As the group’s treasurer, he was in charge of the money bag that was shared by everyone. While Judas did not have a role in organizing Jesus’ crucifixion, the Bible claims that he betrayed his Master for 30 pieces of silver, which was the usual price paid for a slave at the time.
Judas moved from being one of Jesus’ closest companions to becoming a guy whose firstname has become synonymous with betrayal.
Joseph Caiaphas – High Priest of the Jerusalem Temple
Photographs courtesy of Getty Images When Jesus of Nazareth came to Jerusalem, Joseph Caiaphas, the High Priest of the Temple in Jerusalem from 18 to 37 A.D., was one of the most powerful men in ancient Israel, yet he felt threatened by the peace-loving teacher. During the trial and execution of Jesus Christ, he played an important part. Caiaphas was concerned that Jesus might incite an uprising, resulting in a crackdown by the Romans, who were pleased with Caiaphas’ service.
As a result, Caiaphas determined that Jesus would have to die. He accused the Lord of blasphemy, which is a felony punishable by death under Jewish law, and demanded that he be killed. Learn more about Caiaphas’ role in Jesus’ death by reading this article.
Pontius Pilate – Roman Governor of Judea
An illustration shows Pilate washing his hands as he issues orders for Jesus to be flogged and Barabbas to be released from his imprisonment. Eric Thomas is a Getty Images contributor. Pontius Pilate was the Roman Governor of ancient Israel, and he had tremendous authority over life and death. He was the only one who had the authority to put a criminal to death. However, when Jesus was brought before him for trial, Pilate could not find any justification to sentence him to death. Instead, he cruelly flogged Jesus before handing him over to Herod, who subsequently returned him to the cross.
In order to save themselves, they asked that Jesus be crucified, a tortuous punishment reserved exclusively for the most aggressive of offenders.
Learn more about Pontius Pilate’s role in the death of Jesus by watching the video below.
Herod Antipas – Tetrarch of Galilee
The head of John the Baptist is carried to Herod Antipas by Princess Herodias. Stringer / Getty Images / Archive Photos / Stringer Herod Antipas was a tetrarch, or ruler of Galilee and Perea, who was selected by the Romans to serve as their representative. Due to Jesus’ status as a Galilean, who fell under Herod’s jurisdiction, Pilate sent Jesus to him. Herod had already assassinated the famous prophet John the Baptist, who was also Jesus’ friend and kinsman. Jesus was asked to perform a miracle for Herod, rather than finding the truth about what had happened.
Learn more about Herod’s part in the killing of Jesus by reading this article.
Centurion – Officer in Ancient Rome’s Army
Image courtesy of Giorgio Cosulich and stringer/Getty Images. Centurions were battle-hardened army leaders who were trained to kill with sword and spear under the Roman Empire. Jesus of Nazareth was nailed on the cross by a Roman centurion whose name is not revealed in the Bible. This order changed the course of history. The centurion and the troops under his direction executed the crucifixion of Jesus in a cold and methodical manner, following the commands of Governor Pilate. “Surely this guy was the Son of God!” he exclaimed as he gazed up at Jesus, who was hanging on the cross.
The Real Reason Pontius Pilate Ordered Jesus’ Death
Photograph by Renata Sedmakova/Shutterstock When it comes to historically significant individuals, we typically know a great deal about them. Their multiple actions are documented in historical documents, or there are countless tales of a single special feat that they achieved. In accordance with Biography, Pontius Pilate is a historical figure who doesn’t truly fit into either of the above-mentioned categories. We are familiar with him as the Roman authority who ordered the death of Jesus on the cross.
- However, possibly the most crucial question regarding him concerns the true reason for ordering the execution of Jesus, a man who some thought to be the Son of God, as well as his true motivation for doing so.
- Prefect of Judea was a post of immense importance in that area when Pilate was appointed in 26 A.D.
- This, of course, meant punishing anybody or everything who had committed a crime before him.
- This was the situation when Jesus was brought before him to be tried.
Live Science reports that Pilate’s relationship with the people under his rule was tricky to begin with, and it grew much more convoluted once he presided over a contentious trial in the second century. The consequences would reverberate throughout history.
MaintainingRome’s power was the ultimate goal
Shutterstock photo by Renata Sedmakova. The majority of historical people are well-known, and we know a great deal about them in general. Their multiple actions are documented in historical documents, or there are several tales of a single feat that they achieved. Pontius Pilate is a historical figure who, according to Biography, does not truly fit into one of these categories. We are familiar with him as the Roman officer who ordered Jesus’ death. The rest of his background is a mystery to us, as is his personal life.
- Pope Pontius Pilate was a Roman governor who served under Emperor Tiberius, who reigned over the Roman empire during the first century A.D.
- While his responsibilities necessitated that he handle things like infrastructure and taxation, he was also in responsible of preserving order in the provinces that he governed as part of his duties.
- When it came to dispensing punishments in the territories he commanded, he had complete control over the process, which meant he frequently possessed the authority to save or kill those in his possession.
- Live Science reports that Pilate’s relationship with the people under his rule was tricky to begin with, and it grew much more convoluted once he presided over a contentious trial in the first century AD.
Who was responsible for Christ’s death? Who killed Jesus?
QuestionAnswer The solution to this question has a number of different sides. In the first place, there is little question that the religious leaders of Israel were directly or indirectly responsible for Jesus’ killing. “The chief priests and the elders of the people convened in the palace of the high priest, whose name was Caiaphas, and they devised a plan to secretly capture Jesus and murder him,” according to Matthew 26:3–4. The Jewish authorities asked that Jesus be put to death from the Romans (Matthew 27:22–25).
- (John 11:53).
- It was a Roman form of execution approved and carried out by the Romans under the authority of Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor who sentenced Jesus to death on the cross.
- The people of Israel were also participants in Jesus’ execution, as was the Roman Empire.
- Crucify him!” “Crucify him!” the crowd chanted as He faced trial before Pilate (Luke 23:21).
When Peter told the men of Israel in Acts 2:22–23, he was confirming their suspicions: “You, with the assistance of evil men, put him to death by nailing him on the cross.” As it turned out, the murder of Jesus was part of an elaborate conspiratorial scheme that involved the Roman Empire, Herod’s Jewish leaders, and the Jewish people themselves, a diverse group of people who had never worked together before or since, but who came together this one time to plot and carry out an unthinkable act: the assassination of the only begotten Son of God.
- At the end of the day, and maybe quite astonishingly, it was God Himself who executed Jesus.
- Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross insured the redemption of untold millions of people and offered the sole means by which God could forgive sin without compromising His holiness and flawless righteousness, which was otherwise impossible.
- As opposed to being a win for Satan, or a needless tragedy, as some have indicated, it was the most gracious act of God’s grace and mercy, the greatest manifestation of the Father’s love for sinners.
- As the Bible says, “God caused him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that through him, we may become the righteousness of God” (2 Corinthians 5:21).
- He died in order to pay the price for our sins (Romans 5:8; 6:23).
He did it this way to serve as a constant reminder to himself and everyone else that it was our faults that condemned Jesus to death on the cross. Questions regarding Jesus Christ (return to top of page) Who was to blame for the killing of Jesus Christ? Who was responsible for Jesus’ death?
Subscribe to the
Get our Question of the Week emailed to your inbox every weekday morning! Got Questions Ministries is a trademark of Got Questions Ministries, Inc., registered in the state of California in the year 2002. All intellectual property rights are retained. Policy Regarding Personal Information The information on this page was last updated on January 4, 2022.
Pontius Pilate was a Roman governor who served under Tiberius the Great during the first century AD. His most well-known role is that of the judge in Jesus’ trial.
Who Was Pontius Pilate?
Pontius Pilate is thought to have originated from the Samnium area of central Italy, where he was imprisoned. Pontius Pilate was the governor of Judaea from 26 to 36 A.D. throughout his reign. He accused Jesus of treason and said that Jesus considered himself to be the King of the Jews, and he ordered Jesus’ execution. Pilate died in the year 39 A.D. The exact reason of his death has not been determined. His presence was proved by an item discovered in 1961.
Prefect of Judea
In the Samnium area of central Italy, it is claimed that Pontius Pilate was born and raised. The Roman governor of Judaea from 26 to 36 A.D. was Pontius Pilate, who reigned throughout that time. Christ was crucified after being found guilty of treason and declaring that Jesus considered himself to be King of the Jews. Pilate died in 39 A.D., according to the Roman calendar. What caused his death is still a mystery at this point. According to a piece of evidence discovered in 1961, he was alive and well.
Pontius Pilate, as governor of Judaea, was confronted with a clash of interests between the Roman Empire and the Sanhedrin, the Jewish religious council. When Pontius inquired as to whether Jesus was the King of the Jews, he asserted that Jesus had accepted the title, which he never had done. The Roman authority regarded this claim as treasonous and prosecuted the accuser accordingly. Pontius Pilate, according to some historians, worked in collaboration with Jewish officials, who considered Jesus’ claim to authority as a political danger, when it came to pursuing Jesus.
All four of the Gospels portray him as a weak man who eventually caves in to the Jewish rulers’ demand to put Jesus on the cross.
Only Matthew 27:24 describes Pontius Pilate as refusing to participate in Jesus’ crucifixion: “So when Pilate saw that he was gaining nothing, but rather that a riot was beginning, he took water and washed his hands in front of the crowd, saying, “I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves,” he said.
INRI was a Latin abbreviation for Jesus’ given name as well as his title as King of the Jews. Some feel that the term was intended to be sarcastic, in order to criticize Jesus for his lofty assertion.
The circumstances surrounding Pontius Pilate’s death, which occurred about 39 A.D., remain a mystery and a matter of debate. According to some legends, the Roman emperor Caligula ordered Pontius Pilate’s death by execution or suicide, which was carried out. According to some stories, Pontius Pilate was exiled and eventually committed suicide of his own free will. Some stories hold that after committing himself, his body was thrown into the Tiber River, which is where he is buried. Others, on the other hand, feel that Pontius Pilate’s destiny was tied to his conversion to Christianity and his canonization.
Whatever happened to Pontius Pilate in the end, one thing has been established: that he was a real person who lived in the first century A.D.
Antonio Frova discovered a piece of limestone etched with Pontius Pilate’s name in Latin, establishing a link between Pilate and Emperor Tiberius’ reign in the city.
The Crucifixion of Jesus and the Jews
Jesus was executed because he was a Jewish victim of Roman persecution. On this point, all documented authorities are in agreement. His execution was ordered by the Gentile Roman ruler, Pontius Pilate, who had him tortured and killed by Gentile Roman troops before he was executed. In fact, Jesus was one of thousands of Jews who were executed by the Romans. The New Testament not only attests to this fundamental reality, but it also provides for Jewish participation in two ways. A small group of high-ranking Jewish officials who owed their positions and authority to the Romans colluded with the Gentile leaders to have Jesus executed; they are claimed to have been envious of Jesus and to have regarded him as an existential danger to the status quo.
The number of individuals in this mob is not specified, nor is there any explanation provided for their actions (other than the fact that they had been “stirred up,” as stated in Mark 15:11).
As recorded in Matthew, the Roman ruler wipes his hands of Jesus’ blood, as the Jews exclaim, “His blood be upon us and upon our children!” (Matthew 27:25.) Throughout Jesus’ mission, the Jews are shown as desiring to murder him in John’s Gospel (John 5:18,John 7:1,John 8:37).
This shift in emphasis is not entirely clear, but one obvious possibility is that as the church spread throughout the world, Romans rather than Jews became the primary targets of evangelism; as a result, there may have been some motivation to “off-the-hook” the Romans and blame the Jews for Jesus’ death rather than the other way around.
However, by the middle of the second century, the apocryphal Gospel of Peter presents the Romans as Jesus’ supporters, and the Jews as those who crucify him, according to tradition.
As a result, anti-Semitism has fed such beliefs for ages, culminating in the crude demonization of Jews as “Christ-killers.” Christians have traditionally held, in opposition to such predictions, that the human actors responsible for Jesus’ execution are irrelevant: he offered his life voluntarily as a sacrifice for sin (Mark 10:45;John 18:11).
“Let his blood be upon us and upon our children!” cries out the congregation in most liturgical churches when Matthew’s PassionNarrativeis read during a worship service.
In most liturgical churches, when Matthew’s PassionNarrativeis read during a worship service, all members of the congregation are invited to echoMatt 27:25aloud, crying out, “Let his blood be upon us and upon our children!”
Mark Allan Powell is a professor of New Testament at Trinity Lutheran Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota (Columbus, Ohio). He is the editor of the HarperCollins Bible Dictionary and the author of Introducing the New Testament (Baker, 2009) andJesus as a Figure in History (Westminster, 2009). He received his bachelor’s degree from Harvard University. John Knox Publishing Company, 2012). A gathering of individuals who are participating in religious services and are worshiping. The proclamation of “the good news” of Jesus Christ to the entire world.
- spurious gospel purporting to have been authored by the apostle Peter, but which was rejected by the early Roman Catholic Church as part of the canonical New Testament canon because of its apocryphal nature.
- A narrative that has been written, spoken, or recorded.
- God’s character and actions are discussed through writing, conversation, or contemplation.
- 15:1111 (Mark 15:1111) The leading priests, on the other hand, incited the mob to demand that Jesus release Barabbas for them instead.
27:2525 (KJV) Following that, the entire population exclaimed, “His blood be on us and on our children!” 5:1818 (John 5:1818) In order to assassinate him, the Jews increased their efforts even further, believing that he was not only violating the Sabbath but also referring to God as his own Father in the process.
- He did not want to travel about in Judea since the Jews were searching for an occasion to attack him and his family.
- 1 2:14-1514 (Thess 2:14-1514) Because you, brothers and sisters, were models for the churches of God in Christ Jesus that are located in Judea, because you experienced the same things from your own compa, you became imitators of those churches.
- Observe further information 10:45:45 (Mark 10:45:45) The Son of Man, after all, did not come to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” 18:1111 (John 18:1111) “Put your sword back into its sheath,” Jesus instructed Peter to do.
- God, on the other hand, demonstrates his love for us by sending Christ to die for us while we were still sinners.
- More details may be found at1 Tim 1:515 p.m.
When it comes to Christ Jesus coming into the world to help sinners—of which I am the foremost—the phrase is certain and deserving of complete acceptance. Matt. 27:2525 (KJV) Following that, the entire population exclaimed, “His blood be on us and on our children!”
Who is responsible in the crucifixion of Jesus Christ
QUESTION: Who bears the primary responsibility for the crucifixion of Christ? Answer: This subject has been disputed for ages and the discussion continues now – who was the genuine assassin of Jesus Christ. What does the Bible say about this? It is revealed in Matthew 27:22–25 that the Jewish authorities asked that Jesus be crucified. The Romans, on the other hand, were the ones who physically crucified Jesus (Matthew 27:27-37). Who bears the ultimate responsibility for the crucifixion of Jesus Christ?
- Our sins were the cause of His death.
- But God demonstrates His own love toward us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us, according to the Bible’s verse Romans 5:8.
- Pilate was the one who inquired.
- “Crucify him!” they cried out even louder, as if they had something to prove.
- ‘I am not responsible for this man’s blood,’ he insisted.
- They stripped him down to his underwear and draped him in a scarlet robe before twisting a crown of thorns together and placing it on his head.
- ‘Hail, king of the Jews!’ they cried out in jubilation.
- After they had made fun of him, they stripped him of his robe and dressed him in his own clothes.
- ” “As they were about to leave, they came across a man from Cyrene named Simon, whom they forced to carry the cross for them.
- They offered Jesus wine mixed with gall to drink there, but after tasting it, he refused to take any more from the cup.
After he had been nailed to the cross, they divided his clothing by drawing lots for it. They sat down and kept a close eye on him from that position. A written charge against him was placed above his head, which read: THIS IS JESUS, THE KING OF THE JEWISH GENTILES.”
Profiles of Joseph Caiaphas and Pontius Pilate, key figures in the arrest, trial and crucifixion of Jesus.
|Joseph Caiaphas, High Priest (18 C.E.-36 C.E)Joseph Caiaphas was the high priest of Jerusalem who, according to Biblical accounts, sent Jesus to Pilate for his execution.As high priest and chief religious authority in the land, Caiaphas had many important responsibilities, including controlling the Temple treasury, managing the Temple police and other personnel, performing religious rituals, and-central to the passion story-serving as president of the Sanhedrin, the Jewish council and court that reportedly considered the case of Jesus.The high priest had another, more controversial function in first-century Jerusalem: serving as a sort of liaison between Roman authority and the Jewish population.High priests, drawn from the Sadducean aristocracy, received their appointment from Rome since the time of Herod the Great, and Rome looked to high priests to keep the Jewish populace in line.We know from other cases (such as one incident in 66 C.E.) that Roman prefects might demand that high priests arrest and turn over Jews seen as agitators.Caiaphas was the son-in-law of Annas, high priest from 6 to 15 C.E. and head of a family that would control the high priesthood for most of the first century.Annas is also mentioned in Biblical accounts.It is possible that he, as a high priest emeritus, might have served at the side of Caiaphas in the Sanhedrin called to resolve the fate of Jesus.Although little is known of Caiaphas, historians infer from his long tenure as high priest, from 18 to 36 C.E., that he must have worked well with Roman authority.For ten years, Caiaphas served with Roman prefect Pontius Pilate.The two presumably had a close relationship.It is likely that Caiaphas and Pilate had standing arrangements for how to deal with subversive persons such as Jesus.Caiaphas’s motives in turning Jesus over to Pilate are a subject of speculation.Some historians suggest that he had little choice.Others argue that Caiaphas saw Jesus as a threat to the existing religious order.He might have believed that if Jesus wasn’t restrained or even executed that the Romans might end their relative tolerance of Jewish institutions.High priests, including Caiaphas, were both respected and despised by the Jewish population.As the highest religious authority, they were seen as playing a critical role in religious life and the Sanhedrin.At the same time, however, many Jews resented the close relationship that high priest maintained with Roman authorities and suspected them of taking bribes or practicing other forms of corruption.In the year 36 C.E., both Caiaphas and Pilate were dismissed from office by Syrian governor, Vitellius, according to Jewish historian Josephus.It seems likely that the cause of their dismissal was growing public unhappiness with their close cooperation.Rome might have perceived the need for a conciliatory gesture to Jews whose sensibilities had been offended by the two leaders. Josephus described the high priests of the family of Annas as “heartless when they sit in judgment.”Unlike other Temple priests, Caiaphas, as a high priest, lived in Jerusalem’s Upper City, a wealthy section inhabited by the city’s powers-that-be.His home almost certainly was constructed around a large courtyard.Archaeologists discovered in 1990 in a family tomb in Abu Tor, two miles south of Jerusalem, an ossuary, or bone box, containing on its side the name of Joseph Caiaphas, written in Aramaic.The ossuary is assumed to be genuine.||Pontius Pilate, Roman Prefect (26 C.E. -36 C.E.)Pontius Pilate was the Roman prefect (governor) of Judea, a subprovince of Syria, who ordered the crucifixion of Jesus.As prefect, Pilate commanded Roman military units, authorized construction projects, arranged for the collection of imperial taxes, and decidedcivil and criminal cases.During his ten-year tenure as prefect, Pilate had numerous confrontations with his Jewish subjects.According to Jewish historian Josephus, Pilate’s decision to bring into the holy city of Jerusalem “by night and under cover effigies of Caesar” outraged Jews who considered the images idolatrous.Jews carried their protest to Pilate’s base in Caesaria.Pilate threatened the protesters with death, but when they appeared willing to accept martyrdom he relented and removed the offending images.Again according to Josephus, Pilate provoked another outcry from his Jewish subjects when he used Temple funds to build an aqueduct.It seems likely that at the time of the trial of Jesus, civil unrest had again broken out in Jerusalem.Pilate’s lack of concern for Jewish sensibilities was accompanied, according to Philo writing in 41 C.E, by corruption and brutality.Philo wrote that Pilate’s tenure was associated with “briberies, insults, robberies, outrages, wanton injustices, constantly repeated executions without trial, and ceaseless and grievous cruelty.”Philo may have overstated the case, but there is little to suggest that Pilate would have any serious reservations about executing a Jewish rabble-rouser such as Jesus.Although Pilate spent most of his time in the coastal town of Caesaria, he traveled to Jerusalem for important Jewish festivals.While in Jerusalem, he stayed in the praetorium, which-there is a debate about this-was either a former palace of Herod the Great or a fortress located at the northwest corner of the Temple Mount.(Josephus reported that Pilate resided at the palace.)Christian accounts of the trial of Jesus suggest either that Pilate played no direct role in the decision to execute Jesus (Peter), or that he ordered the crucifixion of Jesus with some reluctance (Mark) or with great reluctance (Luke, John).Many historians attribute these accounts to efforts by early Christians to make their message more palatable to Roman audiences.It is clear that prefects had a variety of options available for dealing with a potential source of trouble such as Jesus.These options included flogging, sending the matter back to the Sanhedrin, or referring the case to Herod Antipas, ruler of Galilee.Given what is known about Pilate’s concern with crowd control, it is hard to imagine that he would not have willingly acceded to a request from high Jewish officials to deal harshly with anyone who proclaimed himself “King of the Jews.”Pilate undoubtedly knew that past messianic claims had led to civil unrest.It seems likely that he would have been eager to end the potential threat to the existing order presented by the subversive theology of Jesus. The form of execution used-crucifixion- establishes that Jesus was condemned as a violator of Roman, not Jewish, law.Pilate’s repeated difficulties with his Jewish subjects was the apparent cause of his removal from office in 36 C.E. by Syrian governor Vitellius.Following his removal from office, Pilate was ordered to Rome to face complaints of excessive cruelty.He was exiled in Vienne, France.|
Why Did Pontius Pilate Allow Jesus to Be Crucified?
Pontius Pilate seems to vanish from the pages of the Gospels almost as quickly as he emerges. Despite this, this Roman soldier plays such a significant part in the crucifixion that he is mentioned in the Apostles’ Creed as a result. As one of the most essential explanations of Jesus, what he performed on earth, and the many other fundamental teachings and beliefs that are central to the Christian faith, the Apostles’ Creed may well be the most important summary available. Those who have read about Pilate in the Gospel stories may recall him as a man who saw that Jesus was innocent, but who allowed his fear of the multitude to overpower his judgment.
The story of Pilate may be found in Matthew 27 and John 18:28-40, among other places.
He couldn’t bear the thought of allowing a guiltless guy to endure such a horrific death.
We’ll get into these and other questions in further detail below.
Who Was Pontius Pilate?
The Roman prefect (or governor) of Judea in the early first century was Pontius Pilate. He was known for his harsh treatment of the Jews (about 26-36 AD). Following a referral from one of Emperor Tiberius’ favorite administrators, a man named Sejanus, according to Encyclopedia Britannica, Pilate rose to a prominent position in the Roman government. Despite achieving such a high position, Pilate caused havoc for the government from the beginning of his administration. Pilate had fallen out of favor with Emperor Tiberius as a result of his insulting the religion of the Jews and running an administration characterized by “corruption, violence, robberies, and ill treatment of the people.” When Sejanus, the administrator who found Pilate the position, disappeared from the picture – having murdered Tiberius’ son and plotting to assassinate the Emperor himself – Pilate came under even closer scrutiny from the Emperor.Every move he made was scrutinized.
Given that the guy who suggested Pilate ended up attempting to assassinate the Emperor in the first place, any man Sejanus trusted had to be treated with suspicion.Now, caught in the middle of his own fate and acts, Pilate finds himself in the company of a Jewish man with whom he has no disagreement.
The mob threatens to inform Caesar (John 19:12) if he does not comply with their demands.
They do, however, state their views clearly.
Pilate caves in and authorizes them to crucify Jesus, wiping his hands clean of any blood that could be spilt during the process.
Why Did Pontius Pilate Crucify Jesus?
Despite the fact that Pilate clearly possessed considerable power, why would he sentence a guilty man to death? Even if he looks to be ignoring his conscience, wouldn’t the act of doing so haunt him nearly to death, knowing that he has doomed a sinless man to die, be a source of great anxiety for him? We must bear in mind a number of factors that contributed to Pontius Pilate’s decision to yield to the throng. After all of the evidence stated above, it should come as no surprise that Pilate was in poor status with Caesar.
- And the Jews believed that siding with Jesus was a grave error.
- For the second time, we’ll see that opponents of Christianity frequently assert that the Bible is untrustworthy and that Jesus may have never been at all.
- If you want a more in-depth explanation of this, see Lee Strobel’s book “The Case for Christ.” In truth, Jesus’ ministry – with a few notable exceptions, such as the woman at the well – was solely for the benefit of the Jewish people of the time.
- The Romans were largely uninterested in Jewish matters.
- According to their records, he was in compliance with their tax regulations and otherwise a good citizen (Mark 12:17).
- Furthermore, unless the Jews were leading a revolt or insurrection against Rome, the Romans were not very interested in the affairs of the Jews.
- Furthermore, Romans regarded persons who held Roman citizenship as being of higher significance than those who did not hold it.
- Despite the fact that Pilate understood he was innocent, he did not plan to risk his career and his life for a non-Roman citizen.
As Billy Graham describes in this piece, Pilate was morally bankrupt in his third and last act. In spite of his convictions that Jesus should not have been put to death, he neglected his conscience and succumbed to peer pressure from the surrounding community.
Why Is Pontius Pilate Included in the Creed?
Pilate even goes so far as to wash his hands of the wrongdoing, figuratively speaking (Matthew 27:24). The Jews did not legally condemn Jesus to death, did they? If this is true, then why does the Creed state that Jesus was “crucified by Pontius Pilate?” In the story recorded in Matthew 27, Pilate is given the opportunity to release Jesus, but he declines to do so. However, even if he abstains from interfering with the execution, he still plays a role in the process of carrying out the punishment.
- The stoning method was used by the Jewish people to murder individuals (Acts 7:54-60).
- Furthermore, Don Stewart notes that it was a Roman type of punishment reserved solely for people of the lowest social status, criminals, and rebels, as Don Stewart discusses in this article.
- Considering that individuals who were killed were regarded “cursed,” as Stewart indicates above, it is possible that Jews brought Jesus before the Roman authorities.
- Because crucifixion was a Roman method of punishment, and because Pilate stood there with his hands up and let the crowd to do whatever they wished, Jesus was brought to be killed by him, as well.
Why Does This Matter?
When it comes to the crucifixion of Jesus, it’s critical that we understand who Pilate was and what role he played. First and foremost, we may learn from Pilate what not to do when we are troubled by a stirring in our conscience. However, despite Pilate’s repeated assurances that Jesus is innocent, the crowd stationed outside is successful in convincing him otherwise. Secondly, by understanding about Pilate’s past, including his disagreement with Caesar, we may better appreciate why Pilate would be reluctant to take a chance on a Jew.
- The killing of Christ was a collaborative effort between Jews and Gentiles, we can see that at its conclusion.
- Credit for the image goes to Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain Image/Antonio Ciseri on the Internet Archive.
- More than 1,200 of her pieces have been published in a variety of journals, ranging from Writer’s Digest to Keys for Kids, among others.
- Jenkins and Michelle Medlock Adams.
She is also a co-author of the Dear Heroduology, which was published by INtense Publications and is available for purchase online. Her inspirational adult novel Picture Imperfect, which will be released in November of 2021, will also be released. You may learn more about her by visiting her website.
Pontius Pilate: The Man Who Sentenced Jesus Christ to Death
Christ in the presence of Pilate Mihály Munkácsy, 1881, Hungarian National Gallery; Pilate washing his hands, by Nicolaus Mosman, after Matthias Stom, 1744-1787, The British Museum; and Pilate washing his hands, by Nicolaus Mosman, after Matthias Stom, 1881, Hungarian National Gallery. In human history, Pontius Pilate is one of the most divisive and, at the same time, mysterious characters to have ever existed. Despite the fact that it was not his objective, his activities resulted in the establishment of a universal religion.
- At the very least, on this scale?
- Christ before Pontius Pilate, 493 – 526, Basilica of Saint Apollinaire Nuovo, via Europeana, Rome, Italy Pilate Pontius was a Roman prefect of Judea who is most known for sentencing Jesus Christ to death in the book of Matthew.
- The governor’s existence is only partially documented by archaeological evidence.
- What little is known about this historical figure is based on folklore and unsubstantiated traditions that exist on the precipice of historical fact and religious belief.
- According to the four Gospels, Pilate sentences Jesus to death after hearing accusations from the Jewish community.
- So that they would not be held responsible for anything, the Romans pretended to be the ones who would attempt to avert the crucifixion at all costs if there was any prospect of success.
- 1625-1630, is housed in the Louvre.
- He was harsh and merciless, and he was well-versed in the techniques of his trade.
- The fact that he has such extraordinary leadership abilities is sufficient evidence.
Pontius Pilate In Judea
Aqueduct built by the Romans at Caesarea. Pilate’s responsibilities were essentially military in nature when he first arrived in Judea. In the Roman province, he was successful in maintaining a calm atmosphere. It is important to note that the capital was Ceasarea Maritima, not Jerusalem, as many people believe. In the same way that every Roman was, Pilate Pontius was a very devout individual. The Romans were distinguished by two characteristics: they were brutal warriors in combat and exceedingly pious when it came to the observance of religious regulations dedicated to their gods.
For all of the empire’s emperors, the religion of gods and politics had become inextricably intertwined.
Inscriptions from Caesarea, which were constructed during the reign of Emperor Tiberius, are among the few surviving pieces of evidence of Pilate’s authority. Additionally, coins struck during this period demonstrate that Pontius Pilate is a historical character.
Pontius Pilate’s First Orders In Judaea
The British Museum has a painting of Pilate washing his hands by Nicolaus Mosman, after Matthias Stom, which dates from 1744-1787. According to Roman sources, Pilate is a long cry from the Christian figure that is assigned to him in the Scriptures. He understood how to scare a mob and keep order in an area that was rebellious to authority. His initial activities as a prosecutor in Judea came dangerously close to resulting in a bloodbath. Soldiers from Rome were to be dispatched to the Holy Land, according to his commands.
- The enraged Jews demonstrated in front of Pilate, who devised a plot to scare them away from the city.
- As soon as Pilate led the Jews inside his palace, he ordered his men to draw their swords in preparation for battle.
- The Jews, on the other hand, were brought to their knees and did not attempt to fight back or flee.
- Pilate retreated because his first responsibility was to keep calm among the populace.
The Role Of Pilate In The History Of Jesus
The Sacrament of Ordination, often known as The Kimbell Art Museum houses a painting by Nicolas Poussin, who lived between 1636 and 1640. The fact is that Jesus was not the first Messiah to emerge in Judea, as is often believed today. There had been others before him, each with their own set of new religious ideas. The Romans were aware of them and were continually on their trail. The trial of Jesus began on the basis of allegations brought against him by prominent members of society. That the nobility in Jerusalem had a hand in the execution of Jesus Christ is established by this evidence.
- There are several distinct stories of Christ’s true conviction, which may be found in the Bible.
- After announcing the decision, Pilate washed his hands and recited a few prayers to the gods, as was customary for Roman rulers to begin the day after receiving the judgement.
- According to another source, there were multiple trials before the final conviction was reached.
- According to some traditions, Pilate felt that Jesus was innocent and even stated as much when they arrested and tried him.
- Pontius Pilate is a character about whom we know very little.
He lived and served as the governor of Judea throughout Jesus’ trial and execution, though, and this is all we do know about him. Historical researchers and archaeologists are the only ones who can uncover the genuine facts about one of the most important persons in human history.
Pontius Pilate’s Disappearance
Christ in the presence of Pilate The Hungarian National Gallery has a painting by Mihály Munkácsy from 1881. After Pilate’s ten-year tenure over Judea, there is practically nothing recorded about him in the Bible. He was expelled from the country and returned to Rome, where he essentially vanished. After his return, there was no more published about him or his exploits. The Emperor Caligula, according to some, ordered his execution, while others say he was banished after his last years of power were fruitless.
He may have even gotten another post and continued his life in the Roman Empire, for all we know.
Pontius Pilate In Art
“Can you define truth?” Geoffrey Chaucer’s Christ and Pilate The Tretyakov Gallery has a painting by Nikolay Nikolaevich from 1890. Depictions of Pontius Pilate in art have been extremely popular from early Christian times, particularly after the 4th century CE, and have continued to be so up to the current day. He is frequently shown alongside Jesus Christ, or he is shown washing his hands in confession. Despite the fact that there are several pieces of art that depict Pilate washing his hands, one of the most bizarre depictions of Pilate washing his hands is found in a painting by J.M.W.
In spite of the fact that the artwork was created in 1830, its use of color might be considered impressionist at a period when impressionism was not yet in existence.
Leo Tolstoy, the Russian author, considered this to be one of his favorite pieces of art.
Many artists have chosen to show Pilate at the moment he cries “Ecce Homo” (Behold the Man) when presenting Christ to the Jewish people just before the crucifixion, which occurred shortly before Christ’s death.
Pilate has also featured as a fictional character in literature, playing a significant role in medieval passion plays as well as a number of literary works centered on the life of Christ.
ARTICLE RECOMMENDED FOR READING: Leonardo da Vinci was a Renaissance artist who lived from 1452 until 1519.